High Court of TripuraWP(C)/321/2015disposed of

Manik Debnath And ORS v. The State Of Tripura And ORS

2015-08-13Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra19 pages

!" # $

! $ %

& & !" ' ( ) (* %

(* & +

!" , ( - -& . - * -" - /

/ !" 0 .

* &

& 1 /

/ !" 2 31 ! ." 3/ / !" 4 . 31 . +

3/ / !" 5 ".

31 6! ( .

/ / !" 7 "!8". (* 3/9 - & (*

9"%"3/ / !" ")

3/9 $ %

( 3/ / !" - "

3/9

& +

3/ / !" # ") 31 6! ( .

3/ / !" ' $ * 3/9 ( .

( $'1( .

3/ / !"

31."* ( : "

3/( : / !" 0 !-& 31$ "-& & +

3/ / !" 2 8 3/9

8". " !

3/ / !" 4 6"

3/9 & $ ;/ !

!" 5 " " 3/9

3/ / !" 7 . 3/9 6%

." 3/ / !" # "

3/9 6 * !( $

3/! / !" # $ * 31 - *

3/ / !" ## .

31$ 6!

3/ / !" #' - 31-. - *

3/ / !" #,

31*

& +

3/ / !" #0 "

" 31-)" "

" %&." /( .

3/ / !" #2 -. ("

" 3/9 )"

" 9 . 3/ / !" #4 8 . 3/9 ( .

( $1( .

3/ / !" #5

" 319 <.

" .

1 ;1- 3/- /-

" -

(

- =

- ( 1

1 !" #7 .

3/9 "

1 1-!" /-

" ;>1 ) -

(

- =

- ( 1 1 !" ' ) " 31%

" .

1 1-!" /-

" ;>1 ) -

8 .

%&." 1

1 !" '

3/96!

- !"

" / $ / $ !" '# 3/%

8". ! % ! ?/ $ !" /477' '' ( ) 3/9" ( . " /

!" /477 ',

* 3/ .

* -

;

/ " . - !" '0

3/8 9 " /- /477# '2 $ * %

3/9 % $/#2%&

- >/ $ /477' !" '4 $ * 3/9

"!"- /- !" '5 - .

3/9 - .

,28 $ ;

/% ! /. - !" '7 3/) 00 *

( 8 ;

/ ! !"

* 3/9$!

* ;

/ " /

/. !" ,

3/9

;

/"% .! ." /% .! ." /- /477' ,# (

" 3/(

" ;

/ " /( . /. !" ,' "

3/$ ) ;

/ / /477# ,, %

3/(

;

/ !

/ $ !" ,0 ;=

-& 3/$*

-& ;

>/ !

/ /477, ,2 8 %

3/9*

;>>/- ! ) /477# ,4 !

3/9*%

;

>/% ! 1. !" +$/477' ,5 . 31 !

8". ;

1- 1

. 1. !" ,7 $ 319.

;

>1% ! 1. !" 0 .6 319 .

& 6 ;

>1- ) 1

1 !" +$/477 0 ( 8 - 319$ - ;

1- !"

"1 $ 1 $ !" 0# $ * )

31$. )

;

1- !"

"1 $ 1 $ !"

0' +

)- 31( - ;

1- !"

"1 $ 1 $ !" 0, 8 319 9 ;

>1 1 !" 00 9 31( ;

>16

( 1 !" 02 - "

319%

8".

;>1 !

!" 04 .& !

% * 3/$. % * $/$ -(.

!" +$/477 05 .9 <.

3/ %

( .

/( .

!" +$/477 07 . )

3/9 $/#'- !"

"$ !

) %" /"

"$ !" +$/477' 2 "

3/98 $/#,- !"

"/"

"$ !" +$/477' 2

3/9 " ")* $ /")* $ !" +$/477' 2# ) 3/9" @ !"8

)8 6

/6. *

- !" / /477 2' * . -&. 3/$ 6! -&. 8 - !"

" $/#7 !" / $ /477' 2, -& ) 3/ " ." A !"

20 *

3/9

$/'#8

!" /477, 22 8 )".

3/- " )".

- /"

"$ !" /477' 24 ! 3/9

")* $ $/# /")* .

$ "!" /477## 25 $

3/9$ 6!

) !" 27 )

6 ) - !" 4 % ( ) * 3/9

% * 72-

/( - : "/ = /

!" /4775 4 )

3/9 !

!" "/ = / /477' 4# ( ) 3/6"

, * . ;

/- /"

"$ /477' 4' .

- .

3/9$ - .

$/0 $ % ! "

!" /477' 4,

)

3/$ * %

#4 *

!" /477 40 " 3/9

%&." $/# - ( /477 42 ) 3/9 8 $ $ "

$ %

%" 8

!" 477 44 -! 3/6""% "

( !" /477 45 & !

- 3/9( -

$/09 - "%" !" /477 47 8 %

3/$ %

/ - *

/ / !" 5

" 3/9 & %("

" +

$ 6

( $/'$ /6

& !

!" /477 5 .- 3/9$ * $/'# )".

" !

!" /477 5# !

3/9$. * - . !"$ -8( " = / !" / /477 5' . .

3/$

* -" ( .

!" /477# 5,

* 3/9$ *

* $ 8

") /+

$ /$ 8

!" /4772 50

3/6

% $/2( $/'/ & / "/ = / /4774 52 * . 3/9"

8". $/0$- . !" % /477 54 & !

8". 3198%

07$-(% 1

1 !" /477 55 $ * ("

31$ ("

#509

" B * C;19

." 1! !" /4777 57 & !

- .

3/ !

- .

4#- .

;

/ / /477 7 )8". $ . 3/6! $ . - !"

"- /

/ !"

7 .% .!

31$ ! %

(

.* 2-(

1 !" 7# ) 319$ * (

1 !

1 !" 7'

86"! 31

8". 6"! (

( 1 1 1 !" 7, 8". 6"! 31

8". 6"! (

( 1 1 1 !"

! !" B !

* %..

". * @

= !.

! .

$ & -"

$ &% ! %.! <8"

) !" +$/4772 # "

! %! B !

* "

! %..

! %! %*% %&." +$/477 ' "

! %..

! %! %*% %&." +$/477 , A "

! %! %*% %&." +$/477 0 "!

B C $ & .;=

C !" +$/477 2 %

%&."

!" /477 4 %

!" /477 5 6

D" A -

%&." !" /477

!"#

$ %$& ' ((

A !

)- )

= A !

$?0/5)-% = 6

A !

$#,)88 =

= * )* "

'+#,-

.# # ./ -*.

& = .

& .

#BC

B 9=

(

;

C#, =

!"!

* "

! %! = != 'B'C & *

. *

"= *!

'BC

" !"! & 'BC !=

& ;

%..

& "!

. * !

" "= * <

& "

" E"

"= *

" = * = * 'B#C

& ;

%..

#B.C " <

"= * ..

") . .

!!" & :

& *

. *

& !

! * =

'B'C !=

" F$

. *

"= * !

"/ BC

G =

&" "

. , * & ;

%..

") " .

& !

" = *

" "

& ;

%..

&" <"= *

*. .*.

* .

& = "

! !

* !

&" = !

" . * !

.*.

. &

&" = =

B C !"

H BC

= .

& !

* "= * "

! %! FIIIIII =

(" .

G $ "

= &!

! . * ) &

* (

; *

'4#0 = &

'4#0

%" !

!!!

8 8

! %! .

05#0 & !

. * 0 . )- )

) !

(" % ! ;/ 6 " %" (" &

* %" !"

* 6 " %"

#770C A !"! != (" % ! ;/ 6 " %"(" <

! !

! !" " #

! " !" $ + "

* & * .

" * $

7577# &

! ! (" % ! ;3E"

= %

& " # " # "! $ != &

6 " %" & "

& .

" = * &

& !

* =

= " "

& = ! * . ! * & !! +

! ! !=

! !! &

.!"

! ! " .!*

* =

= " & &

" F+ " ! .!"

!= *!=

< ! .

! ! (" % ! ;3 ("

! !!

< !

!! . *

* =

= " &

! "

= "

!! -" " & =

= "

!! "

* ! *

= " %" & ! ! %% & * <

& !

* "

= " &

1 " ! = * ! . "* + * &

= " )

& !

& ! !

(" %% !! ! !!

& !=

* 6 " %" 2 E"

. *

* (

* & &!

$5 ! . & !

. = ! "

$5 & !

! !

* - )

& !

5. * = * = ! & !

6 " %" "

* ! . & &

& *&" ! &!

. !! &

. *

" " & & " & &!

* !

= = 'B'C

;

B 9=

(

;

C#,+ '()*) +

# '

, -./0 .

/1- !

< " &

! ! & 2

, -.-0 .-

4.5& !

<" .

& ! =

'()*) +

# '

(

# !

/ 6# .#

,+/.

(

3 # ,$ //78+

* 2

<" .! :

* ""

= & !=

<"& ! =

-" & !

(

3 # !

/ 6#.#

,+/.

(

3 # ,

@ = * = & 0#, + & !

! "

& !

* & !

= "

! , & !

= " !

! & "

! %!

& . =

* "

! %! < ! &

! %! =

* !! =

= "

& !

= " !

& =

= .. .

" "

< .

. * " 8 -%

= 6

$ !"

* .

! %!

* = = = *

. * :

& !

= * "

& !

* "

= 6

6= .

!" *

$A2B'0C/@

@ 3#,3'##/#7

#02#0 "

!!! " "

;

B 9=

(

;

C#,

*" "

!" "

! 77, 9

= 6

" !!

%" *

* " .

;

B 9=

(

;

C #,

!" "

! 77, " "

* = * "

"= * &"

" "

& ;

%..

& &" "

* ="

* ! &"

& " !! &!

&" *"

* !"* + = & .

= 6

" & !

= *

&" =

;

B 9=

(

;

C #,

" .!

" . * .

!" "

! 77,

&" "= * E"

* = .

& *.! .

;

B 9=

(

;

C #, - !

& %"

= & * = . B

!& C

&&!

! &+ + " ) 6" 3 7 % #

, -- 0.

45 !

<" =

J .8 "&

9 #

) " ) % " !

: ## # !

# # ! "

# 9 # "

# # # ! " ; ;

<! # # # ! ) )

# ! =

8 ") &

# "

) > ,0 ? ; ; 9 # )

# ! )@ ,!0 ? # " 9 # ) ! # , ) #

! " " ! "0 !" 9 # !" #

# ! # 9 ,

9 " " ) 0 ,0? ) 9 # ) , 0 ?

" 9 # ) " !

9 ) , 0?

0 ,0 8 ) 9 !"

! ! # 9 ? 9

!" # # ) "

; # A

# A "

B! 9 ) !" ! " #

# ! ; "

# ! ! ";; ";# ,#0 8 ) 9 !" B B " " ! # 9 !" "B

9" "@ ,08 # # ) 9 # #

! !) ,' " ! ) #

) # #! 0@

,0 % ## !" 9 # ) # # ,

" ! # # )

## #

9 ) 0 8 ! 3 # ; < " )

" " ! # 6

3 # ;< " )

" ) = C "$ + = .

!"!

* * !

=" """ . (* - .

= . ) - )

= 8 " $ =

*" = !

6! ")

( ) (* ( - " ".

"! 8". (* - "

- K *! $-#0#0

= = !"

" ! " . *

6! ( ) (*( - =

" !

&" * !

. !

$0507222#2'

2, & !

& !

!& B;

. CL

" !

. $ =

" = %" *

&"= .

* (

! !

= .

= . = * " (

* "" < "

" & !

= . = & &

* !

< " + " ) 6" 3 7 % #

' 9 -