High Court of TripuraWP(C)/430/2011allowed

Dhiman Singha v. State Of Tripura And3 ORS.

2015-09-22The Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S.C.Das,Hon'Ble The Chief Justice Deepak Gupta9 pages

ShriDhimanSingha,

" # $" %%%% 1.TheStateofTripura, " & ' ' (

&) * $+ * ,- * +# ' * . /

$"# "' 2.TheDeputySecretary, (

&) * $+ * ,- * +# ' * . /

" $"# "' 3.TheDirectorofHealthServices,

&* . /

" $"# "' 4.ShriS.K.Saha, ' **"" + * 1 2" $"# %%%%%%

) :3 4 *

&-'

3 * 04 ' 0&-'

)" & " :3 &-'

&&- +5& * 6& :22.09.2015

$)+

: Yes No √

!"#$

!"#$% # % # % # % #&' &' &' &'

# *

" + " '

& & *

* +* "-'

& *

&" "' & &

"*"

& "& "' & "- & 2. # + + '" + '

" 7

1 " '

& 8998 3* ""& '&

" &

" #

" ""

& & &

&"' + " &" &"'

"' &'& """.

* &

& + ++' -& " 8:;88 '

* ' '" "' '&

& "& . & 3. # +

& ""& ' &" +"

!"#$% &'!( ')#*++, - . ./ "!0."!" 1) '! ./0.2&.3%) 4 '5%. ) 5 %!

!364.%! .3 5 '! 0'%$!/ 7%8!"

$.3/ -'%. '.83 -.3$'# 3/2!0 .3$ 77.0!%

%4$ # !& ' 8.&)!&7%! !2% 8!3 #59 57 %.24% -# '! 59!%35%# %.24% 053/."!%/ ' 3 364.%) 77.0!% /'54&" 1! 225.3 !" 5 %!

!364.%!.3 5 '!0'%$!7%8!"$.3/ '.8 5:# # '!59!%35%#%.24%.3 24%/430! 57 /41 %4&! * 57 4&! 57 ;;- ;; 4&!/# (, '!%!1) 225.3 -%. -< -'# -2!0.& ;588.//.53!% 57 !2% 8!3 & 364.%.!/# 59!%38!3 57 %.24%# $% & / 364.%.3$ 4 '5%. ) 5 %!

!364.%! .3 5 '! 0'%$!/ 7%8!" $.3/ -'%. '.83-.3$'#3/2!0 .3$77.0!% %4$ # 004/!"77.0!% =)5%"!%3".3 '!38!57 '!59!%35%# /" -8 =.323. !1=%8

!24 )-!0%! %) 5 '! 59!%38!3 57%.24%> 4. "'

&& "&' +" "!3595 &

& ++' & < 2 ' "+ *&

"*# 7

" '&

& + '&

-& ' ++'&

& + &"'

* "&

+ &"*""

+* "-' +& "&"*""&

& ' " 5. # * & "& " & & & ;

8 '" ""+"' & '&

"+ - &

& + '&

" ' &+"' &* - & 6. 1" &" &+" =6>"

" '

" # " &

''&

'""; +=6>"& " ' 7

& &" +"

< ,0 .5353 '!.364.%)%!25% '! ./0.2&.3%) 4 '5%. )# .7 . ./ 35 . /!&7 '! 364.%.3$ 4 '5%. ) 8)# 75% %!/53/ 5 1! %!05%"!" 1) . .3 :%. .3$# %!8. '! 0/! 5 '! 364.%.3$ 4 '5%. ) 75% 74% '!% .364.%) 3" %!25% 3" '! 364.%.3$4 '5%. )/'&& '!%!42532%50!!" 5'5&" '!74% '!%.364.%)005%".3$ 5 '!2%59./.53/574&! #/7%/8)1! ? * '! ./0.2&.3%)4 '5%. )/'&&75%:%"5%04/! 51!75%:%"!"052)57 '!%!25% 57 '!.364.%)#.7 3)#'!&"1) '! ./0.2&.3%)4 '5%. )5%:'!%! '!

./0.2&.3%)4 '5%. )./35 '!364.%.3$4 '5%. )# 052)57 '!%!25% 57 '!364.%.3$4 '5%. ) 5$! '!% :. ' . / 5:3 !3 .9! %!/53/ 75% "./$%!!8!3 # .7 3)# :. ' '! 7.3".3$/ 57 364.%.3$ 4 '5%. ) 53 3) % .0&! 57 0'%$! 5 '! 59!%38!3 /!%93 :'5 /'&& 1! %!64.%!" 5 /418. # .7 '! /5 "!/.%!/# './ :%. !3 %!2%!/!3 .53 5% /418.//.53 5 '!

./0.2&.3%)4 '5%. ):. '.37.7 !!3")/#.%%!/2!0 .9! 57 :'! '!% '! %!25% ./ 7954%1&! 5% 35 5 '! 59!%38!3 /!%93 * '! ./0.2&.3%)4 '5%. )/'&&053/."!% '! %!2%!/!3 .53#.73)#/418. !"1) '!59!%38!3

/!%93 3" %!05%" . / 7.3".3$/ 1!75%! 2%50!!".3$ 74% '!%.3 '!8 !%//2!0.7.!".3/41 %4&!/ @ 3" A @ 7 '! ./0.2&.3%)4 '5%. )'9.3$%!$%" 5. / 7.3".3$/53&&5%3)57 '!% .0&!/570'%$!./57 '! 52.3.53 ' 3) 57 '! 2!3& .!/ /2!0.7.!" .3 ;&4/!/ .

5 .9 574&!/'54&"1!.825/!"53 '! 59!%38!3 -!%93 # . /'&&# 35 :. '/ 3".3$ 3) '.3$ 053 .3!" .3 4&! # 8B! 3 5%"!% .825/.3$/40'2!3& )C %59."" ' .3!9!%)0/!:'!%!. ./3!0!//%) 5053/4& '!;588.//.53# '!%!05%"57 '!.364.%) /'&& 1! 75%:%"!" 1) '! ./0.2&.3%) 4 '5%. ) 5 '!;588.//.5375%. / "9.0!3"/40'"9.0!/'&& 1! B!3.3 5053/."% .531!75%!8B.3$3)5%"!% .825/.3$3)2!3& )53 '!59!%38!3 /!%93 7 '! ./0.2&.3%) 4 '5%. ) '9.3$ %!$%" 5 . / 7.3".3$/53&&5%3)57 '!% .0&!/570'%$!3"53 '!1/./57 '!!9."30!""40!""4%.3$ '!.364.%) ./57 '!52.3.53 ' 3)57 '!2!3& .!//2!0.7.!".3 ;&4/!/ 9 5 .D 574&!/'54&"1!.825/!"53 '! 59!%38!3 /!%93 # . /'&& 8B! 3 5%"!% .825/.3$/40'2!3& )3".

/'&&35 1!3!0!//%) 5 $.9! '! 59!%38!3 /!%93 3) 5225% 43. ) 57 8B.3$%!2%!/!3 .5353 '!2!3& )2%525/!" 51! .825/!"C %59."" ' .3!9!%)0/!:'!%!. ./3!0!//%) 5053/4& '!;588.//.53# '!%!05%"57 '!.364.%) /'&& 1! 75%:%"!" 1) '! ./0.2&.3%) 4 '5%. ) 5 '!;588.//.5375%. / "9.0!3"/40'"9.0!/'&& 1! B!3 .3 5 053/."% .53 1!75%! 8B.3$ 3 5%"!% .825/.3$ 3) /40' 2!3& ) 53 '! 59!%38!3 -!

7. <=;>+; -"

" " &"'

""+ 2

+ ++'+&"'

+ &" + '&

" "& & *" '& " " " + '*

"' + &

& + *" * '

" 2

+ +

& * &"'

#+ " ' * & & " "< " + ' -" *

' +& +" "! 3595 #

"& " - " '+' &"'

+'&

" " "

* '

" ++' *"" + '

" *

" *" " '7 "

* '& +

''&

' ++'" *

*" * "

*#&"?%!8. E

&?74% '!%.364.%)E - *

+& "' * & &; =;>" ' + & "

* ' ' &'& 8. )* + *

* &"'

*" - " " " @" ' *

* 1 " +*

* 7+ ' 0& * + .

!"#$%#

#&&%' .

;A& "+"

< @ /!!8/ 54/ ' 4&!,#53 '!70!57. #%!&&) 2%59."!/ 75% 53! .364.%) 14 . 8) 1! 25//.1&! .7 .3

2% .04&% 0/! '!%! '/ 1!!3 35 2%52!% !364.%) 1!04/!/58!/!%.54/"!7!0 '/0%!2 .3 5 '!.364.%) 5%/58!.825% 3 :. 3!//!/:!%!35 9.&1&! '! .8! 57 '! .364.%) 5% :!%! 35 !D8.3!" 75% /58! 5 '!% %!/53# '! ./0.2&.3%) 4 '5%. ) 8) /B '! 364.%)77.0!% 5%!05%"74% '!%!9."!30! 9. $ . "&" " "" &+' "* *

""" - .

* & 2

++' ' *

&'* " - 7 ' "& -&+ ++'&"'

" *&""1'

" & '7 * 2

++'+' &'

''&

' 10. ; =8> & " &++ " #" ' * " " -& ' '&

+ -& '

'&& &"'

" + - + &

'&& 2

++'.

& 2 ++' "

"-& '+ 1 "' '

"&"'

"&'& &'

& - " 2%.8 70.! - " " + &"

+ 2

& '** '

" "& 2 ++' -

* '

' + "'

"2"+&"'

11. # + &"'

" 2& ' "& " @" - "

" " - & 2 ++' + ' "&

&"'

+* " "" + -& ' #" &" -"

+" ""+ -& ' & '&& 2

++' ' " 7 12. #" ' *"&"'

" +" 1 " '

" &"'

&& +

+ - "1 '

" &"'

"+- " * "+"* * """ & '&& "* * -& ' & 7 ' "& &"'

"& -'&&" "

& '& - *&* 2

++''

+ *"+; =;>#" & $ & " & +" ++'

& " "! 3595 ' " *"" & # '& +&" $+ - "

"& '&

&2 "&&"*""

+*"-' 13. # " +"-'+*9:8; ( " &'& " & "-' + A;" '*8; B+ '7<

"" &*+

& +* & + " &"*""

+* "-' " " * (- & +* & + " *

" " * " ' & &" " +.

'* '*=>

& "-' +" '&

& +" 14. $""- " "&" "&+ JUDGECHIEFJUSTICE