Smt.Bakul Das Suklabaidya v. Binoy Bh. Dey And 3 ORS.
Smt. Bakul Das (Suklabaidya), wife of Shri Iresh Chandra Suklabaidya, resident of Vill. Ashram Palli(Saidabari), P.S. Kumarghat, P.O. Kumarghat, Dist. North Tripura ....... Petitioner 1.
Shri Binoy Bhusan Dey, son of late Ramesh Chandra Dey 2.
Shri Samiran Dey, son of late Ramesh Chandra Dey 3.
Shri Bishnupada Dey, son of late Ramesh Chandra Dey - all are residents of village Nedavi, P.O. & P.S. Kumarghat, Dist. North Tripura 4.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Home Department, Govt. of Tripura, Civil Secretariat, Agartala, New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P. S. New Capital Complex, Dist. West Tripura ...... Respondent
For the appellant :
Mr. D. C. Roy, Advocate For the respondents :
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Advocate Mr. S. Datta, Advocate Date of hearing :
25.06.2015 Date of judgment & order :
13.07.2015 Whether fit for reporting :
Yes
118
!
!
"
#! $ % "
& '
&$ (
) *) + ,
-!. / !
/ / $ 0
!
"#
"$ $ % # &''& () *++, !
-
!
. !
/ - 0 *1+2132142 152
! %
,545
-
218
!
. -. &
/$ &
/
% 1 "
& '(
2 3 4* / /
5 4$
/ /4 //
6 3 /
/ -. ! 8 !8
$ /
) ,
/
!9 9 !8 /
/ / :
53$ / ;
/
:
53$
, /
/ $ / // <
4 <
-8. =
$$
$
318
/ / = / > ?
=
/
/
@ ! -9. &
&
4 $ // / > / / $ $ & $
-. ; 3
6
% 1 /
$
& '/
"
9#! # (*(8*(+* (*
&$ (
) *) + 3
-+. /
A
"
! $
0
6
418
7 ( 2 !
1
2
8 #
2
&' - 9,:'''0/19 2 ;< ( = % "8! - > "8! ! > < "8!
,:'*&''3
(
2 &*'3&''3 ?9
;
; 9
-
%
-
%9 %9 = ,@&0&''3 &*'3&''3 "8! %
,':
% 12 -
- 1
2 " -
-
2
)
- " - 1 2 ;- -
- 1 2
-
- 1 2 > < -
- "8! %
;
; &&'3&''3 %9
>'4'@&''3
518
A
= >89 ,:,1>20'30B0 ,':0 % 2 &@'@&''3
<
- 8 = ,'&50'30B0 ,3,
% (
)
>
= ! " A &:'@&''3 < - 1 2 ;
; -
- " - - ;- -
-
<
-
-
> = *50&''3
,++ %
> "(
'&':&''3 >"(
> = '&0&''@
,++ % ;
;
,5',&''@
>
2
;- !
= '40&''@ (
) 1)
2 " = ! ;
;
;<
0%
0% ?
61 2 C1
2
618
C1
2 C 1 2
0 C <
) 1)
2 "( ?
.
) 1)
2"(
.
!
) 1)
2"(
,:'*&''3
A ;< ;-
=
2 ;
; !
= +'0&''@
!
= '40&''@ ;- ;< (
) "( = ! ! (
)
(
) 1)
2 "(
< (
) 1)
2
718
"( &4'@&''@
! < (
) "( &3,,&''@
2
< #
>
> = @+0&''3 &5,&&''3 0 ,+3
%
;- A2 ?
< (
) 1)
2 "(
0%
*1,21 2
!1%
2 ,545 1A2 < (
) 1)
2 ?9 0%
;-
* 1,2 1
2
! 1%
2 ,545 1A 2
0% ;
.
* 1,21A2
! 1%
2 ,545 1A
2
9:''''0/1 A2 A
0% !
818
(
? 6
0 *1,21 21
21A2
@
?9 0%
;
; 9 9
% "8!
0 *1,21 21
21A2
@
?9 0%
;
;
; % "8! ! @50&',' ,@'5&',' "8! %
<
-. 3
6 3 /
$ /
$ / / $ % "
& ' $
B C $ :
/ -. 1 4 $
"
!
'/
"
9#! 5 $5
/ $
918
(!*
0 !
/
1,2 A
D
-. ) 1 4 $ /
&
$ $ /
/
$
1 4 $
$ = E
#E
1,5::2+
,*: ) >
,
5
D
& $ /$ D
3 /
/
>
$ / / / $
: $3 E
//
:
1018
@
//
& > 0 F = F
.
.
*5:1&2 ,5:*
#
<
*5: ,5:*
!
<
*5:1&2 ,5:*
;
<
<
#
. -?/
.
1118
-!. 1 4 $
> ( >
1,5::2+
33, $ 0 ,&
A
-
&&
# ( G :+&
,@'@7 <
!
D ,@': 7
<
D
. ,@'4 :++:+3
7
1,2 <
1&2 <
<
-
.
1218
-. 3
$ 1 4 $
$ > ( > = $ /$
> 0 F
A
,**1,2
H
A <
;
/
I$ 9 &
%
;
J
,,3
%
F -
< - A
.
*5:1&2. -?/
.
1318
-. : $ > ( > 5
$
$
/
(!*
&
$ $ / B
-8. :
/ /
/
$
5 /
/ ; /
5
/ $
$ $
$
$
$ / $
$
& / B C
(!* $
$ :/
/ /
/
$ ) $
1418
$ $ -9. )
$ 5
$5
$
"
! -. 1 @
/ $/ % /
$ / : / 5 /
/
-+. :
;
;
1&'',2,
*@5 $ 0 !
! A
>% " -/ 1,5552 ,,
+*5 -?/
. -. 1 @
3
1518
/
6 (*
@
(!*
/:
53$ -!. & / A
+! $ $
%
$ / / $6
A
/ 0 ?
6
;- 1
2
. -!. 1 @ $/ B
$< /
$
>
& , /
> $ $
$ % &
/ 5 $ / $ , /
$ $ / -!!. 1 @ / A
, / /
( * ( * (>* (>*
1618
&$ (
) *) + =
0 * %
/ 1,2 F
! / KKKKK 2 F
!
L KKKKK
2
A
! L A2
<
! 1A2
!
KKKKK -!. D $/
/ $
1718
/
$/
( * ( * (>* (>*
&$ (
) *) + / , -!. & % 2 3 / "
& 4 / / >
$ -!8. :
/
E @
1818