High Court of TripuraLA.App./74/2011partly allowed

State Of Tripura And 2 ORS. v. Ranu Ch. Dey

2015-07-22Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra11 pages

! " #!$% & ' (& % $

)

#$ *+ #!$% & ' (& % $

) , - #$ . +/!"+ #!$% & ' (& % $

) &" 0 #$ 1111111

## 23 2 *

& # *

& 4 5# $ # & !6$ 1 1111

## 8 4 &

"! 7

8 &

"! & 9 : $ ;

√ 111

" < 8 4 &# !

## 5## 8 & #

! :

!= !

- '

5 #" 8 ! ( ) >:

!= ? $ #* . ! ' # '

! #

' ! !#

% @.A '-

4 # B&"

:@A>:@A >5 != # 5

# # ' ?5 #! B

! 7 @()"> !=>C03>@@ D @@@

!= ! D@

7 @()"> !=>03>@@

! A !

!= *##! '

= #

"# A:

% " "

6 211

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l.

No.

Deed No. & Date Plot No.

Class Amount Per kani value Average rate 1.

1-1139 dt.21.2.97 175,176,1 Nal, Pukur, Pukur Par Rs.90,000/- Rs.10,00,000/- Rs.7,81,42,750/- 2.

1-2951 dt. 14.5.97 16268 Viti Rs. 40,000/- Rs.6,40,0000/- 3.

1-1853 dt.20.4.98 523,524, 525,526, 613,527, 526/5509 Viti Rs.12,000/- Rs.6,85,710/- 4.

1-1854 dt.20.4.98 -DoViti, Nal, Pukur Rs.1,00,000/- Rs. 8,00,000/- /&'.))4(.(/0'0% '(6'1;+/ $< 9 =>?0$%5'+:%0+.,%0$%',-*.+%)&'()$'/ 0 1% '//%//%) ',,+).(3 0 '7%+'3% +.,% 0$% +%&%7'(0 '() ,5'+'1&% /'&% .(/0'(,%/ +%&.%)*('()(0',,+).(30/'&%.(/0'(,%/ 4$.,$ 5.3$0 1% %0,$.(3 0$% 5'8.5*5 +.,% %+%9 $'7% 0':%( !*+" ,5'+'1&% /'&% .(/0'(,%/0$%5'+:%07'&*%4$.,$./+'(3.(3 +5?&',/0$*/'()0&',/$%'7%+'3% 5'+:%0+.,%!/%7%("/'&%)%%)/,5%/0

/9>9<@ 0 $'/ 1%%( .(0%) *0 .( 0$% +%3.(3 '+'3+'$/ 0$'0 0$% &'() *()%+ ',-*./.0.( ./ 0$%+(0'3%&'()$%&)120$%60%)'+/4$.,$ 311

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

*##!

E !#' F

! D ! D@ ! 8 ! ( ) >:

!= ? $ # * - '

5 " 6 B $%,&'.5'(0$'/+%&.%)*('/'&%)%%) 5'+:%) '/ 810 4$.,$ /$4/ 0$'0 A'+' A+'(0''()G)$+/&'()4%+%/&)'00$% ,(/.)%+'0.(

/?9<@ .%

/ B99<@ %+ :'(. ( 0$% 0$%+ $'()9 0$% &&%,0+ '&/ '))*,%) ,2 /'&% )%%) *()%+810/%+.%/+54$.,$.0'%'+/0$'0 0$%&'()4'//&)F /99<@%+:'(.0 ./'(')5.00%)',00$'00$%',-*.+%)&'()./7.0. ,&'// &'() 0 ./ (%%)&%// 0 5%(0.( $%+% 0$'07.0.,&'//&'()'&4'2/%0,$$.3$%++.,% 0$'( 0$'0 0$%+ &'()/ $% ,&'.5'(09 $4%7%+9 ,&'.5%) / ++% %+ :'(. 1*0 ( 411

/'&%)%%)$'/1%%(/*15.00%)( 1%$'&0$% ,&'.5'(0 /$4.(3 0$% 7'&*'0.( 0$% &'() F

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

0 ,(7%(.%(00'/,%+0'.(0$%5'+:%07'&*%0$% ',-*.+%)&'()$%%).(30$%)%,./.(0$%'+%@ %8+%//%)'/%90$%+%%++.(3,&'.5'(0/'+% %(0.0&%) 0 /B99<@ %+ :'(. 1'/.

0$% +8.5'0% )'0% /'&% .(/0'(,%/ '/ 0$%.+ +%/%,0.7%/$'+% A 8 4 & #

## !## 5

= "# - '

5 7 # !

"# 5 # '! # # B:.D (+/ ) 5

! ! ' ! - !

# #! #

" BB" #

! +/ # ! " ! 0

-! '

# +/ !' "

5 /' #

! 5## '

# 0

! 8 &# !

# # ! /! '+5%/$4'+.%7.;/ *(6'1 0'0%&%,0+.,.02'+) == 5 / ! # 6 #0./4%&&/%00&%)&'40$'0.0./0$%)*020$% ,&'.5'(0 0 +7% 0$% /'&% )%%)/ 12 '))*,.(3 %7.)%(,% %.0$%+ 0$% 7%()+ + 7%()%% + '00%/0.(3 4.0(%// '//.(3 0$% ,(/.)%+'0.(*()%+0$%/'&%)%%)90+7%0$'0 0$% /'&% 0+'(/',0.(/ '+% 3%(*.(% 0+'(/',0.(/ 611

1%04%%(0$%4.&&.(37%()+'()4.&&.(37%()%%I 0$'00$% ,(/.)%+'0.( $') .( ',01%%( '//%) *()%+ 0$% ),*5%(0 )*&2 +%3./0%+%)9 +%+%/%(0 0$%+%7'.&.(35'+:%07'&*%I'()'&/0$%&'()/ *()%+',-*./.0.('()0$%&'()/,(,%+(.(30$% /'&% '+% /.5.&'+&2 /.0*'0%) '() //%//%) /'5% + /.5.&'+ ('0*+%9 ')7'(0'3%/ %0, $% 1*+)%(./'&4'2/(0$%,&'.5'(0J

8 & #

# ' 5#

!= *##! ' ## !

# #

"# 5#

' 5 5! /! ! < ! +/ #

"# # 5 ! ! -

5# # ! - !' 8 & #

# ' " ' %

' +/

! 5 !=

!5 " != ## # #5 '

! ' ##' 711

D 7' 8 & # !

# 5# ! -! '

## " ' " ! #

5! 5 # *##! ' '%

' " # !

' 5! !

" !

"# ! #

5! 5

# !

*##! 8 & #

# ' ' #

' ' !

- # #B 4 # '##

! +/ 5 '# " #

"# ! " '!## @ 8 & #

' ' -! '

# +/ !

-! ? 0 8 & #

# ' #

! +/ !

! '! +/ ' " ! ##5 "

5 -! '

## !

##5 811

! = '

# /' "

8 4 & #

# ! ! 8 & # !

# = ! /! 0'0%'+2'(';/ '5 .(3$

E?5 /! "

6 #0 4'/ $%&) 0$'0 12 7.+0*% %,0.( C@9 ' ,%+0..%) ,2 ' ),*5%(0 +%3./0%+%) *()%+ 0$% %3./0+'0.( ,09 => .(,&*).(3 ' ,2 *()%+ %,0.(C0$%,05'21%',,%0%)'/ %7.)%(,% 0$% 0+'(/',0.( +%,+)%) .( /*,$ ),*5%(0/0./%(00$%*+00',,%00$% ,%+0..%),2'/+%&.'1&%%7.)%(,%'()4.0$*0 %8'5.(.(3'+0.%/00$%),*5%(0/$./)%/ (0$4%7%++%,&*)%0$%*+0+5+%6%,0.(3 0$% 0+'(/',0.( .0/%& '/ 1%.(3 5'&' .)% + /$'5 +7.)%) /*,$ ' ,$'&&%(3% ./ &'.) 1%+% 0$% *+0J !'() ,-*./.0.( .,%+ '() '()'& %7%(*% .,%+ ;/ ; '+'/'.'$ !"B CB" 8 & # !

' ! !## # !

## !# ' !-! < ' ! ! # # /'

# #

"# # /'

# ! !

# 911

! '# ! '

! ' - ' !##

# <" '

' #

! - ' ! "5!

' != #

5" '##' # !''!##

# #B4 #

# 5 "# '% # ! 5! !

/!# ' !

5 #

"# !'

+/ 5 !.

!= ? !! "#' . % ! . % !! !

# !"! != !

@@@

# +/ B5 /! !## (5) "5 ! 5" ! -! +/ G(G

) ! ! G#

1011

"# !' (. B A@) H A

!! ! 5# #

"# %

## # #

# !'

I G

! .( )

!= !

#' .G

! .()

!= ! # 5 '

! D @@@ '

! .

!= !

# "#

"5 ! ' ! '

"# $ "

# ##5 5 !! #

5 * 5

J; 1111