Bhabatosh Roy v. State Of Tripura And 2 ORS.
Sri Bhabatosh Roy, son of late Sukumar Roy, resident of Vill. Bhogjor, P.O. & P.S. Bamutia, Sub-Division : Agartala, District: West Tripura .........Petitioner - V E R S U S - 1.
The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Department of Science, Technology & Environment, having office at New Civil Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Sub-Division : Agartala, District: West Tripura 2.
The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Department of Finance, having office at New Civil Secretariat Complex, Gurkhabasti, P. O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Sub-Division : Agartala, District : West Tripura 3.
The Director, Department of Science, Technology & Environment, having his office at P. N. Complex, Gurkhabasti, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex, Sub-Division : Agartala, District: West Tripura .........Respondents
!
1
!"#$%&'%!(!$(
! " # $
%
$ & &' $
( )
*
+
,-. /0001 ./2,12 !!
-
3
# 2 ( *
-00
( *
-0 &
( *
-0
*
( 4
5
6 $ 5867+59/'1-50+/,.1:!!:,-
&' &
$
2
5
;
52 /.1 "9# 0
2 !&&- < &:-
+ 0 $ $ =
$ . /2,1 2 *
.
/.1$ 2 &
$ *-
9/1
& 4 4
!
"<#
2 !&&- < &:-
2 '<&-9 <&:- ./2,12 & &' &&
&
& &' && 2 4<&-9 <:- "'# 4
.
, /.,- 1 & &' && , > /,>1 + 2 9< &-
&&&:-
2 9&&:- $ 6
3
& & & & / ; - ,- 1 "4# > 6 7
& & & & )
;
.,- 4
& &' $ 6 7
& & & )
;
> ;
;
;
"!# 5 6 7
&4 && / ; -,- 1
&
&< && 5 6 7
& & & $
4
&< &&
., & &' && , > 29< &-
&&&:-/,>- 1
2 9&&:-(
&4 && / ; -,- 1 6 7 + & & & &
4
$
.- .,-
" # 7 ) $
$
& & & & $
4
&< &&
4
&&'
;
! &# 5 $
- $
-
$ $
# 7 $
$
$
;
=
& & & & & & &? $ 7 $
$
.- 29< &-
&&&:-
. /2,1 2
.,
. /2,1 2 &&
5
&&' 29< &-
&&&:- /,>- 1
2 9&&:-
&&'5
$
-
# 5
7 .)$
*$
( @ (
+
,-.000 ./2,12 !!$
2!&&-
< &:-
A
.- & &'
# 7 .)$
*
3
! " "
! #$
%&"
'
% & $' # ()
! * + " ,
-
$
%&"
'
%& .$' # ()(
*! % !+
# /*
/
*
+ "
( "/ +
6
*"
!
0* /
!
! * " +
"/ *" 123 " " !**123 .4516&7'
15&$%'$ 7))(
/*/
0 0 /
"" - ""! +(
0
+ 8 * 1
%
/ /*/ !
8 !
+ " # $
%&"
'
%& $' # () -""! +
*!
%& $' # ( ))) #"0+
*/ #
* ! % -*"/ "
/&/ %-' #" "
*
&#
2' ! 6 & #' " *"/ "/ "
* + ( ( #
+ #
+ " ## "
+
*" "
*
!
*"/ " # * / " /
+ "" / + + *" +0 * *
"0 " *"/ 0+ + / ! # $
9 $
% % & $' # ( )))( #
" /! /
0 "0#/0 " *"/
" "# / + # %- &/ '
+ / +
"
+
!
/
+ " "
! &
!
#$
%&"
'
%& $' # ()
# 0" ** & &' " *"/
(
" /+ 0 "/ "
* ++ *"
/ %-
%& $' # ()))
" (
(
8
+0
3 3* ))
"
+ 7))
/ !( * + "
#$
%&"
'
%& $' # ( )(*. )))"
/
7))
/ ! +
"
(
(7 6( &* ' # 0 0 / %- *
* %& $' # ()( "
0
%- +!*
!
" + 3 3 7
+ #
0
8
!#
0
*0 #0/
%-
4*(
0
%-
( 6) ( 8 7
" 0
!
" # * 0 /
0 + +
"
+ *" /7)
# (-%$ "
+
/ 7) /
0 * /
"
0*
"
/
7))
/ ! + "
7 6 &* ' # 0
/ %- % & $' # ( ))) * $+9 &
6 ( '
$+
7
-%$ "/ #
&!
' + *" %- + *" #0:"
# /
" # %& $' # (); 9# 7.)$
* & &'
$
( /*
-001 2!&&- < &:-/ -
1
&
./2,1 2 > $
& &' && $
2 4<&-9 <:- <#
.-0
A
2!&&- < &
2 '<&- 9 <&:-+ ;
4
& &' && ./2,12 && '# 7 .)$
*
$
.,- ,>- 29< &-
&&&:-
2 9&&:- 4
$
.,- !
$A
8
2 & ./2,1 2 && 4# (
$
=
.3 &' <
0
*"
8 +0 0+ * #
. ". ))
# *!
0 #
%-
-%$= &' <
"
7))
/ " 0
" / :#
&%- ' / #
%& $' # ()))= &' #
! 8
* + /# +(
" 0 "* /
!*""#/
" = !# > =
$
$
!&' & <
)
$) ; 2!&&- <&&:- # 7 .)$
*
(.
% (
& !4$ <( " &# 5 $
4&
/1 $
9
( $ A
0 (
2 4&-'<&:- $ ./2,12 !!
2!&&- < &:- # 0
&& <
$
A <
2 44 *52 &9 5
'&!
(
2!&&- < &:- 5
;
3
"
*
# (
&%
>'
#
2 / ?# ?# /
?#/
8
!
"
!
!
"
* 0
.*"
* @8 *"/ .
"
( 7 & 8'
" # 3 # "" % ( -! 3
!
7 "
!! "
* / / !/ # 5%@ "# "
A
0
! !/ / ! "//"/ #"
!
"" %
"" % A +
#"
!
/
#"
7
* ! 0"A
% -
/ / 5%@ !/
#!
#
0+ +/ /!7 0?# "# (
2
( #! " & *'
" +
( & * ';
10
# 0 +
!&'
. 7 ) %
-
(.0 ;
+ 9 + + !
3 -
/(
/ !# 0
5 18 +
9# + <A
2 / (
/
"
( # # !
%# ( -! 9"
" ! :#
" " 2 < *
/
-
/(
/ !# 0
5 18 +
9# + <A
2 / ( /
"
(
# # !
%# ( -! 9"
" ! :#
" " 2 < *
/
"(
2 /
*"
!
%#
30 !
%#
# *"
"
" < /
/
# 0 " ( "0 "#
*/ ! "
"# / ( 0
!
"
-""! +(* "
"
(
"/ #
+-
/(
/ !# 0
5 18 +
9# + <A
2 / ( /
"
( # # !
%# ( -! 9"
" ! :#
" " < *
/
-
/(
/ !# 0
5 18 +
9# + <A
2 / (
/
"
( # # !
%# ( -! 9"
" ! :#
" " 2 < *
/
""
* !#
/
) 5 2 <
2 / !
0*5 8 +
; " # 5
&4 && / ; ,-
1 &
11
$
; 2 4<&-9 <>
& & & & $
., 2 9< &-
&&&:- /,>- 1
2
9&&- 4
;
> ;
& & & & ; ,- <
0
*"
8 + 0 0+ * #
. ". ))
# *!
0 #
%-
-%$= #
! - 5
! ; 2-
$
$
" 9# B %
12
;0
2"
"# %
@!! . " 3 -
" .
* 4
.
- )) % 7( ; C
- $ )
D " <# (
; .
/.1
2 & ./2,1 2
.
, /.,1 ./2,1 2
$
$
$
& &' $
( $ 2!&&- < &:- <
"
7))
/ " 0
" / :#
&%- ' / #
* + # ()))* + # ( )= " '#
- E
(
13
$
$
./2,12 0$ 2 &./2,12 3 % -*"/ "
/ &4 '
"
/ ))) *
*/ / +
*
" *"/ 0+ +
/ ( ! "
0+ / 0# /*/
!
" 0 -8# - +
*"
*" &'
/ + !0+"
"# /
" 5
/ -8# - " !
"
*
" *"/
( + " ## "
+ *"
" (B
" ( 6 "
* + #
+ !
/
!
" 0
"
! &0'
/ + !0+"
"# /
8
! " 6 * " 5 " ! " * " *"/ 8 !
" 0 -8# 3-3
+ " ## B "
+ *"
+ "
!
"
/ ! *"/ "
* +(
" /+0(
!
" #
+! / !
" 0
"0 "
! &"'
/ + !0+"
"# /
" 0* & ))7 "
) )7 " " ! " ' * " *"/
8 !
" 0 -8#3-3
+ " ## B "
+ *"
+ " #
+ ! / !
" 0
"0 &'
/ + % *" * " *" "0
-8# 9
0 "
* /))) &'
" / 0# *"/
!
" + 0 8#1
&'&'
" 4# $ $
14
-
;
$
" !# 0 $
$
$
- $ )
-
-
./2,12
" # 0 )
2 & ./2,1 2
.-0
= $ &# ./2,1 2 &&
.
/.1+
.
, /.,1 @ &&' $
./2,1 2 && 2 & &&
$ *
.,
- *
15
*
-
: $
.,
: -
$ $
.,
# . 2 & ./2,1 2 &&
3 &
4
/ 4
1 !
/ <
1
- # 0
2!&&-
< &:- -
( 2!<&-
&:- / -
1
$
2!&&- < &:- .-0 $
$
16
$
=
& & & & ; ,- $ =
& & & =
#
$
&4 && 8 .-0 $
; 2 4<&-9 <:-6 4
4
& &' $ $ ; ; ,>-0 29< &-
&&&:-
2 <&&:- $
., !
<
#
! 8
* + /# +
" 0 "* /
!*""#/
" = 9# 0 $
$
= = 0
<# 7.)$
*
(. ?,/.1 + 9 &&' /$ A
& &
1
17
?,/.1 + '' &
/$ A
& & <1 $
'# A $
. $
& &'
$ 4# (
;
$
$
7 .)$
*$
)
18