Ashis Chakraborty v. State Of Tripura And 9 ORS.


 


    





 
 




  
 
 
  


  


 
! "

 !

 #$




  
  
" 
%"


!   
& 
  
()
" 

  *
 +,- 
+% 
  

 
! "

#.

!"


/ 
%"



& 
  
 +  
+ 
  

 
! "

#

" ++  

&
0"
 
1"
2 
 +,- 
+ 
  


 
! "

#3




 "
4  "

5
!"



!   
/ 
%"


 +  
+ 
  


 
! "

#6
 
,  
!
&
" 

" ++  

!
0  
& '


0"
 
1"


 +,- 
+% 
  


 
! "

#7

 
! 
4 "


" 

" ++  

!
0  
& '


0"
 
1"


 +,- 
+% 
  


 
! "

#
 
  
& 
4 "


" 

" ++  

!
0  
& '


0"
 
1"


 +,- 
+% 
  


 
! "

#8

 
,
1 
4 "


" 

" ++  

!
0  
& '


0"
 
1"


 +,- 
+% 
  


 
! "

#9
 
 
2

" -
&
" 

" ++  

!
0  
& '


0"
 
1"



 +,- 
+% 
  


 
! "

$#
 

& 
:! ;
&
" 

" ++  

!
0  
& '


0"
 
1"


 +,- 
+% 
  


 
! "

"# $

"
%  
&%'

( )
)


< 
*0


 
'

<
( $

3

*0
5
0 -
'

<
( 6


$#

*0

,
 
'

<
( 7
*0

!


'



!


 

*+,-
!'
5 



  








 (.$/0

1 $!$ !!12 / 
0


 
 
"


 




)

0
5
0 -
 
" 
 
 
( $
.

=
3
0

,
 
 

 
 
( 6

8
9

$#

0

!


 
"


 

( 
7

2
 

) 

 
 
 
"   

( 6
7

8
9

$#

 
  
- 

 
)






4 "


"




> "


 

 
)


( 6
7

8
9

$#
)

  


 
 
> 





 
$$..#$#



( 3
4
  

 
 

 
 

>


  
2 

4'


:24

 ;


 
 

( 6
7

8
9

$#

3 " 

" 
 

'  .##7$99
2

' 
"


)
' 
 

 
"  
 ' 0  
! 

0"
 
2+0"
 
 
& 0"
 
4


  
) 


 


"


 "


) 


 ' > 
> "



   
 
'
 .##7$99
4

 



  
 
" 
"

( $
.





)  
:;
( 3.8

$99

 
) ) 
"

 
#7#..##
< 
 
"

 


*  "


?
 





           



     

        !      "      # $  %& '

())*+ , - . "  

     $    $   / "#    0       1  !     2 "

        # $    

  $       3 3       0           !  "  0  $        4" 3#   5   0    " 3   $ 

     # $   $                3 $  3

      # $      

 + , - .

       "    $       4    5# 

   "    +*.  3      $  

     4" " 3  " 

 

 

     $     # $       # $    "   $     3    

        # $ 

    

       $  # $ "     $       "

 $ # $  " 

  $                "      

  2     $        $  #   3         -26                            $   2   $   

 

 $ "     

$         $  $  0  $   #      $  "  $     $    3 # $  2#   $$        !3        $  

    # $   $   $    "#            $              $         $    $        !   #" 

 

 $  

       $          

    $     $        #     3     3 $" 

           "    3

   $   2 $        # $ "         %& '

())*     $    $   "  $    $  7 '&8-        " $   )   #            "   # $ "     /

 2#"#$   "     $ /

9  :




 

 
 
""




 
 
 

 #7#..##
  



)
 

:;
( .

.#$$

 
 -"




/ )'

 

)  )

 
) 
 





2

 
$6#..#$$

 
)


 
:;
( .

.#$$
) 
 )


)  )
) 
 

 "

"

 



 
 


" 


 )

 

- 0
 
 
"


 
 
 
 

 
  

)
 

:;
( 3.8

$99

"

'

( 6
7

8
9

$#
)





 

 "
 


 
'
 
.##7$99
'
) 

"


%'
 



 



) 


 
 
)










 
 "


& 0"
 
4

"



""



0
 
 
"


 

 
)
)




 
 "
 '

  

'  

" 
 "









  
0
 
 
"


 

 
' 
 


) 
4


$.

)
 

 
 
 
" 

"


7



4  
"



"


 
#3$..#$#

""








 "
4  "


!"

/ 
%"


 
  

 

 

                    

   

    



 

 



   



    !



 

   

 

 

   

               



 

    





"" ""#$ %  & 

   ' # (  )  '

         



  ""* +  ,#- . *  )     



/



# /  

      

  

      

 

      '#0#1#$    2  !

      )    



 3 



  %&



   

 

 







# 4     

    5*** 

  

  

 3 





      



  

   

  

   6   #*  

 #7
4

 

' "
 " 
 

 
$$..#$#

 









 
 

  
 
  
" 

"


$9



4  
"


%'

 
 





"


 


) 

'



 




4  
  
2
) 

"








 
   ) 
"  


 
$$..#$#

"


) 
 


  
"
"  

 "
..7

   
4


' 
  


  
 

" 
)

 




  '

"

'

 
'  



 
0  '
 

" 

 

" 


"

( 6
7

8
9

$#




"



 "


'  
.##7$99

,
0
5
0 -
 
"


 
  
( $
.


 
  " 
 

)


 

" 



 
 






 
 "

" 

'
> 





 

 


 '"
 
 ' 


 "
..7

   
4 
 


 

" 




 )


) 
 



 @  
)"

 

"  


) 
A

 
 )

  

" 

'
 "
 

"  





 
) 
  

 


"  

 
0
0 -
 
"


 ) 
' 
 


"

 +
 '
 





( 6

$#



 
"


 


 
) 
 "


 "
 
"



 + 
 "

&
0"
 



'
 .##7$99
0
0 -
 
"


 
 

"

)
 
 


 
$.
 
' 
"


 

 


"








 "

"


  
 
( .


 '
 

-"




   
) 

 "


0

,
 
 
"


 
  
( 6

8
9

$#
 
 


  
 ' 

 
 '
"

" 



)
 
 






'  
.##7$99



 
  



"








 
 "

&
0"
 

 '





 

 


 
+
/ )'




- 

 
 '


 
( $
.


 
 
"

 
( $
.


"




"

"




 



 
( 6
7

8
9

$#





"




'
"
 


 )
 


0

!


 
"


 
 
( 7
 
 "


  
 

0

,
 
 
"



"

 



 



 "

 


'
 
.##7$99


"



  

 



  
 "




&
0"
 
  

( 7


" " 
 "

 

" 


"

  '
'  
 
< 
*+@$
)"


"

"


 
##.$996

 

( 6
) 



 
$996
/"

( 6
 

  
" 


" 






 "



2  

4 
 " 
0"
:B " ;
 
2  
  
B  

""





> "



>' 

  
 

"
< 


  
 #7#..##


:;
( 3.8

$99

) 
 
/ 
 
 
"

" 


"




'
 
.##7$99




 '

>
0  
! 

0"

) 


 
 





 "

 
'  
.##7$99

 '

 "
 
"

 
 

 
#7#..##

 

" 

"



) 

 
 "


  
 
" 
> "


 
"


 

) 


 
 
"



 
) 

> "

"

  
  

 

 
 "

  
*



"  
 


" 

 
) 
" 

)
 
"

 


4


)   C
4

) " 

" 

 3  

 
"

   '

'* 



4
"


$$

 
'
 "
:;

%*   
44

 

 '




)"




 '

 

"


"
 

 



 '





"



   



"
 
4
')

*   


 '

"


$$


 


 "


) 


"



 








) 
 '

 -"





' 
) 
  

" 
 
4
 




) 



 )

" 
 




 
$$..#$#

 

'

) 
"



( 6
7

8
9

$#
)





 + 
 "
 
$.
 





* "


"



"
"


) 

  

& 
1 '
 


 "

 
) 

"


" 

 )

'
"

')

 



 
( $
.



 

   "

"



3
"

) 


 








 
 "

 


 '

 

" 




 

( 6
7

8
9

$#


"

)
 
'





 


""

 





2 

) 

"



 

 
 

'


  
2 

4'


:24;

"
""




"

 

 
  "

"" "

" 


) 



 


 
"
  
 
  
)
 
   

  "

"



'

 
/"

 
 
 
-"








) 

 
'* 
/ )'

"




 " 





 

 





( 4 02