Alpana Nathandanr v. Ashutosh Nath And 22 ORS
THEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA AGARTALA
PLAINTIFFAPPELLANTS: 1.Smti.AlpanaNath,
2.SmtiSatanukaNath(Minor),
!
"
# BYADVOCATES: $
%
&'
%(" $
"
) $
* $
$+ PRINCIPALDEFENDANTRESPONDENTS: 1.ShriAshutoshNath, 2.ShriSudhamoyNath, 3.ShriBhupalChandraNath, ' ( !
"
"
# PROFORMADEFENDANTRESPONDENTS, 4.Smti.BinaBalaNath, 5.SriSukantaNath,
( !
"
"
# 6.Smti.NirmalaNath +
7.ShriPrithishNath,
+ 8.Smti.NirupamaNath, +
% ( !
"
"
# 9.ShriKritiBodhanNath,
')
* !
"
# 10.Smti.ManjusreeNath,
) --./$*
0-112
11.Smti.PragyasreeNath,
$
3 4* !
'
.$ 12.SriTusharKantiNath, 13.ShriTuhinNath, 14.ShriTapanNath, 15.ShriShiponNath, 16.ShriBiswakalyanNath, % $ +
% # *
!
"
# 17.Smt.GambhiraNath,
$ + ( !
"
# 18.ShriApurbaDebnath, 19.ShriAjitKumarDebnath, 20.ShriAnupKumarNath, % $ % * !
"
#
21.Smti.SuptaDebnath,
5#"
6 $ * + !
&
" # 22.Smti.PramilaDas,
$'+
(
"
# PLAINTIFFRESPONDENT: 23.ShriSouravNath,
(
!
"
# BYADVOCATES: $
"
)
%(" $
"
) $
%"
) $
7 #) :23.06.2015. ( 8 ! :10.07.2015. 9 * : Yes No √ # " " 11 + +( " :1; " ) "
1- /1
%
" 8
# # %
0/1 1& %
"
8 ) "
;
/1 1
+( 85 ( 6
# # 5 6 12 /11;
# " "
""
&+
& & < &, "
= " $
%
&'
" $
* " $
"
)
" $
%"
) "
/.
"
" " 6
/ 5 > ?6 # 5 6 12/11; + +( 85 ( 6
# "
/ . 5 > " ?6
@ // > ?6
' >%?> ?
' ""
>+? # "
>%? $) #& > ?
$)"
' & /0
5 6 & $'
2
' A 6 + 5
6 5/6
%
5 "
6 5.6
5 " /6 5@6
+ 5 " .6 506 5& (
@065-6 5& (
- ;6
'
5 6 $ 5& (
:
6 5/6 B 5& (
/ 26 5.6 5& (
; / B " $
" ' & C;
>%?> ?
"
:
& C./
"
# " " ' '(
>%? & "
( '( > ? & "
&
'
&
&
"
& ( '
#
"
"
" & "
" # "
"
/ . A" & @ 1/ /11;5 B 56 5"6 >+? 6 >%? 5 //6 "
/. A" @ 1/ /11;5 B 56
>+? 6
>%? "
#
>%? " & " ( "
# >%?> ?
"" >%?
"
/ . ) & " "
1 1;0"
>%? "
;.- *
1/:- "
" (
@0
# " $ ( " " (
$ $
?
' &
& "
& ""
( "
>%? (
>%? (
"
# "
" > ? $)"
&
" &
@ ; &
> ?
& "
& &
) "
# &
"
&
>%? " A" >+?
A"
" " (
<
# "
"
>%? " " '& '
&
)" & # > ?
@ ; '
(
"' )"
B " " " (
(
& '&
&
8 :;."" " (
>%? > ?
& "
@ ;
> ? & "
(
# "
" "
(
/ @&
" & " A
# 8 "
A
,
!
"#$ !% &" "&&'! "#' !% &" &' ! "## !% &" &'
B "
A A & &
/
) % ' .
+
%
&
( & " " ,
! () ! * ++,,- ./ " () " * %",0$%, + () + * %",0$%% % () % 1
! "#$ "&&' , () , 1
! "#' "&&' 2 () 2 1
! "## "&&# $ () $ 3 - ./ !# !& ' () ' 1 - ./ !"
# () # 1 * ./ # "
" / A A &
/ '
% (" " ( &" ' DA % DA +,
! () 4 * !'+2 - ./ " () 5 * %",0$%% * ./ + () 1 * ,",0$%& * ./
# 8"
""
% (
# %
0 /1 1 + %
" 8
# ) 1- /1
" "
< & " $
&'
8
& "
& "
" &
& & ) "
"" "
"
" + & "
+ & )
" & & ( '
'
@ ;
> ? & " & "
" $
"
) DA / DA .
@/0C2@0 @/0C2@@ & "
" " ' DA + "
&
> ? & "
& B :
" > ? &
' &
'
# " "
& &
'
D( '
' " # " "
> ? &
"
@ ;
""
@ ;& "
&
)" " & & & > ? & "
" ) "
+
& "
# < &
) "
" ( B ( " "
" $
&'"
" $
"
) "
. + & ) & # " ( &
' &
&
'
# " "
& & ' "
"
( '
" " " ?
"
& & (
' * " " DA .DA B & &
@ ; " '
# " &
&
&
"
@ ;
)" # "
A " > ? & "" &
B ( &
& "
"
&
) "
& " # A " " $
&'
" C"
"
C"
" & &
&
"
C"
" A
" <(" (" "
C"
"
C"
"
C"
"< (
= " ( "< ( " $
"
) "
" " " & (
(
& '& '&
&
8 :;.
B ("
( "
" " >%? " (
"
>%?
# " " " $ ( "
#
" $
"
) & A
" "
"
8 ? " %A + " P. Lakshmi Reddy V. L. Lakshmi Reddy, AIR1957SC314. " $
&'
" %A+ " SadasivamV.K.Doraisamy, AIR1996SC 1724. "
" C"
"
C"
"
C"
"
) "
C"
( <(" (" "
C"
"< &(
#
" ""(
" $ (
>%?> ?
# " "
" &
"
&
=
"
(
"
"
(
'
# " "
8 :;.
# '
>%? & "
( DA DA % "
& "
#
"
A " & &
"
&
::/ ::.
B "
A :;/ " "
=
B & (
> ?
# ( > ?
=
&
+ (
>%?
" "
& B" "
# + " P. Lakshmi Reddy(supra) "
" "
& "
(
#
" " &
"
& "
) # "
"
(
"
"
& " # +
& &"
("
" & A" (
) '& "
( %A+ @
) & "
& ,
%
6
77 7 8 - 9 * 2!84$' '": 48;!#+%<1"+ ",
3
6 6 )
7;
- 1* "$84!+2 !%& <1
5
/
=
3
/ 3
> 71 4 !#!"41 "+&
8
)
/
?
3
)
3
? )
) ?
8 < 1 @ < A 48; !#!# <1 %% %$ - 6
1 -
!'%& + <B- ,+# : ," ;; ,22 (
C C 7
D ;
/
48;!#+!<1%' 8
?
B " " (" " "
(
'
B
( " "
" @11C011 "
# "
( >%? /0
& & "
)" "
# "
& ' $ "
& "
>%? &
" & & "
" ::/C ::. "
)" ' :;/ " ( " 1
:;.
B " "< (
" A" (
) '&
# && %A + " P. Lakshmi Reddy(supra) " "
A" (
( "
5 "
6 &
+ & +
( "" & B " Sadasivam5supra) + " " " P. Lakshmi Reddy(supra). # " " Sadasivam(supra) <
"
" =&( &
( %A+ . ) & "
& ,
!+ 8
1
.
) -
F1
)
( -
)
)
-
)
)
* F
)
()
)
3
) )
-
3
)
.
7 !#'%
.
!#', F 6
# ( (
" ("
" " " " " B (
( ""
& " "
"
>%? > ?
& "
@ ;
" )" "
# + "
+ ) "
+
# "
( ""
& "
24.
"' & + " & " ) JUDGE