Subhash Ch. Saha v. The State Of Tripura And 3 ORS


 


        In W. P. (C) No.349 of 2014 Sri Subhash Chandra Saha, son of late Jogesh Chandra Saha, resident of Bardwali, near Milan Sangha, P.O. AD. Nagar- 799003, Agartala, Dist. West Tripura, Tripura ............Petitioner - V E R S U S - 1.

The State of Tripura, represented by the Chief Secretary to the Government of Tripura 2.

The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Finance Department 3.

The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Food, Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs Department all of New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban -799006, Agartala, P.S. New Capital Complex, District : West Tripura 4.

The Director of Food, Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs, P.N. Complex, Gurkha Basti, P.O. Kunjaban -799006, Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, District : West Tripura, Tripura ............Respondents 

   















 






 In W. P. (C) No.481 of 2014 Shri Subrata Pal, son of late Nripendra Mohan Pal, a resident of Ramnagar Road No. 4, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. West Agartala, Dist. West Tripura, Pin: 799002 ............Petitioner -V E R S U S1.

The State of Tripura, through the Principal Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Food, Civil Supplies and 




Consumer Affairs Department, New Capital Complex, P.O. Agartala Secretariat- 799010, Agartala, West Tripura (for self and for the State of Tripura) 2.

The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Finance Department, New Capital Complex, P.O. Agartala Secretariat-799010, Agartala, West Tripura 3.

The Director, Food, Civil Supplies and Consumer Affairs, Pandit Nehru Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin: 799006 ............Respondents 

   



































 








  
  ! "
"





 
 


 
! " 
 

#
 
















!#$%&'()*($+$'++*,



$ 
   

# %& '
()*

+,-)

# %& '
).-

+,-)

 

 

 


""
! " "


  
/ 

 

$ 
    0+1
2




 
 
  
 




 
 



   

# %& '
).-3-)
 


 
  


   

# %& '
()*3-)
 








 






$ 
   


  0(1
4


 



   

 
"


5


4 
6  
 
%46
&
 



 
  
 

 


  

 
 " 



 

4
  
   

  


$
 




 "


  
 "
 
7 "
#
4 
 
8

 


$ 
   

# %& '
).-3-)
"

 
5

 

   

# %& '
()*3-)


 




 "



  
 "
 
7
"
#
4 
  




 "




   




  

 0)1






 

 
 


 
  



   

 / 


" 


 " 


   







  
 "
 
7
"


   


9  

 
 
 "


5


4 
6    
 
 

$3

   

 
 

 

 


$ 


 " 
 
  4




 

   


 " 





 
 
 


   

7 
(


4 
 "
 
7 
-*.:

0;1
4
  


   

  



"

$3



 

"


   

7 
(


4 
 "
  7 
-*.:
$ 
  

 
<



 



  

 



          

            




 
  ! "#!$%&!'( )* ( ! %$(#%+( )#,- $ .// #!+!%0! ( ! $./.#1)*( !2,&3!)*.%$(#%+(),#(%*."")%'(!&)'4 )/! (%-!5.$%$)#.' )')#.#%,-)*$6"!#&.1%*."")%'(!& )' ".#((%-! 5.$%$ ( !# -!-5!#$ %* $%((%'3 )' 4 )/! (%-! 5.$%$7$ .//#!+!%0!.+)'$)/%&.(!& )')#.#%,-)*$"!# -)'(  .'& %* $%((%'3 )' ".#( (%-! 5.$%$7 . +)'$)/%&.(!& )')#.#%,-)*$6"!#&.1*)#( !$%((%'3 
  !"#!$%&!'(.'&( !-!-5!#$)*( !%$(#%+()#,- $ .//5!!'(%(/!&*)#$,+ (#.0!//%'3.//)4.'+!.'&&.%/1 .//)4.'+!)')**%+%./(),#.$.#!.&-%$$%5/!()8#.&!)**%+!#)* ( ! (.(!8)0!#'-!'(

  !$./.#17 )')#.#%,-.'&)( !#.//)4.'+!$$ .//5! &!*#.1!&),()*( !)'$)/%&.(!&,'&)*( ! (.(! 8)0!#'-!'(
 !*)#!."")%'(-!'(7( !"#!$%&!'(.'&-!-5!#$)*( ! %$(#%+()#,-$ .// .0!()(.:!.','&!#(.:%'3( .( !&)!$ ')(.'&4%//')( .0!.'1$,+ *%'.'+%./)#)( !#%'(!#!$($.$%$ /%:!/1().**!+("#!2,&%+%.//1 %$*,'+(%)'$.$.-!-5!# 
 '.&&%(%)')*"#)0%$%)'$)*$!+(%)'  7 (.(! 8)0!#'-!'(-.1#!-)0!*#)-( !)**%+!7( !"#!$%&!'(.'& -!-5!#)*.%$(#%+()#,-4 )
 .

.$5!!'.&2,&3!&.'&%'$)/0!'(7)#
.$5!!'+)'0%+(!&)*.')**%+!4 %+ %'( !)"%'%)')* ( ! (.(!8)0!#'-!'(7%'0)/0!$-)#./(,#"%(,&!7)# +
.$5!+)-!" 1$%+.//1)#-!'(.//1%'+.".5/!)*.+(%'3.$ $,+ -!-5!#7)# 




&
.$.+;,%#!&$,+ *%'.'+%./)#)( !#%'(!#!$(.$%(/%:!/1 ().**!+("#!2,&%+%.//1 %$*,'+(%)'$.$.-!-5!#7)# !

.$$).5,$!& %$")$%(%)'.$()#!'&!# %$+)'(%',.'+! %')**%+!"#!2,&%+%./()( !",5/%+%'(!#!$(  #)0%&!& ( .( ( ! "#!$%&!'( )# -!-5!# $ .// ')( 5! #!-)0!& *#)- %$)**%+!)'( !3#),'&$"!+%*%!&%'+/.,$!$ & .'& !

)*( ! $,5#,/!   !<+!"( )' .' %';,%#1 !/& 51 (.(! 8)0!#'-!'( %' .++)#&.'+!4%( $,+ "#)+!&,#!.$%(-.1$"!+%*1%'( %$5! ./*.'& *%'&$( !-!-5!#()5!3,%/(1)*$,+ 3#),'& =
  !(!#-$.'&+)'&%(%)'$)*( !$!#0%+!)*( !#!$%&!'( .'&( !-!-5!#$)*( !%$(#%+()#,-$ .//')(5!0.#%!&() ( !%#&%$.&0.'(.3!&,#%'3( !%#(!',#!)*)**%+! >
  !#!.'10.+.'+1)++,#$%'( !)**%+!)*( !"#!$%&!'( )* ( ! %$(#%+( )#,-7 ( ! $!'%)#-)$(  %' )#&!# )* ."")%'(-!'( -!-5!#)*%$(#%+()#,-7 )/&%'3)**%+!*)#( ! (%-!5!%'37$ .//&%$+ .#3!( !*,'+(%)'$)*( !"#!$%&!'(,'(%/ . "!#$)' ."")%'(!& () *%// $,+  0.+.'+1 .$$,-!$ ( ! )**%+! )* ( !"#!$%&!'()*( !%$(#%+()#,- ?

  !'( !"#!$%&!'()*( !%$(#%+()#,-%$,'.5/!() &%$+ .#3!( !*,'+(%)'$)4%'3().5$!'+!7%//'!$$7)#.'1)( !# +.,$!7( !$!'%)#-)$( %')#&!#()( !."")%'(-!'( -!-5!# )* ( ! %$(#%+( )#,- $ .// &%$+ .#3! ( ! *,'+(%)'$ )* ( ! "#!$%&!'( ,'(%/ ( ! &.1 )' 4 %+  ( ! "#!$%&!'( #!$,-!$ ( ! + .#3!)* %$*,'+(%)'$
  !"#!$%&!'()#.'1-!-5!#+!.$%'3() )/&)**%+!.$ $,+  $ .// ')( )/& .'1."")%'(-!'( %')# 5! +)''!+(!& 4%(  ( !-.'.3!-!'()#.&-%'%$(#.(%)')*.')#3.'%$.(%)')*4 %+  .0!5!!'( !$,52!+()*.'1"#)+!!&%'3,'&!#( ! +(&,#%'3 %$(!',#!*)#."!#%)&)*1!.#$*#)-( !&.(!)'4 %+ +!.$!$ () )/&$,+ )**%+!# @ -" .$%$/.%&*)##!*!#!'+!A 
0=1



 
 


   

" 


  


   
 " 


" 
"
>7 
-

7 
(

4 
 "

 
7 
-*.:
 

/ 
$ 










 



>7 
-

7 
(


 

  


  
"


 

 


6 


  


 

$ 
 "
 

   "

7
-;,3>



 


 "
  4


 


   
$3
 



 "
 
 





 
 


   

$3
   


 


6 


  



   
$3


/ 

 


? @


$3
 
 

$ 

$


   
 0:1



 

$3
  
 

"


" "  
$ 

  
"   




  



   

 





" 

?



"


  




 " 
 @
 

"
 
    

 " 





#
4 
  
 "
7
"

  
 


 "

 

+, ,* -(
 

   
9
 
   

 






  
"
 
    

$  

 $
 

 

"


 
"

 




    0.1


 






 

  


   
$3

 




 "



  
 "





 
7
"
#
4 
  


"

;
% &


=;
% 9
 &


 
$ 

  4
   

# %& '
()*3-)
$
 



   

,+ -+ -(
''!<,#!


# 
  
 
$

   

# %&
'
).-3-)
$
 


'   

+- -+ -+
''!<,#!


$ 
  



'    



 


 
 " 





  
 "
 
7
"
#
4 
  
 

$ 





"



  



 " 
 
  


  

"

 




 " 
A
"
 
    


 " 
$


 



   

4 
 "

 
7 
-*.:

" 
"
 "

 "
4
   

 

$ 




"



   
 

 
$ 

  " 





$ 
   

 

 " 

 


   
4
$

$

 




9 


   



 
  




 
 
"





   

$

 $  


 

$
8 
 " 

 






$ 

$
5

 

 


$
$ 


 




 "



  
 "
 
7 




"

"




 


 
  

  
  
 
 
  


  
 

7 
(
%-&


 
  


 




 "



  
 "
 
7
"




 


6 

  

4
$

 
 

"  


  
 
" " 


 


  




   "
"

>7 
-

7 
(


 

 




  
  

 

   
3

 


   

 " 
$ 
$
"
9 
 


" "    




 
 

  "
5
 
 
 


  




   

 

  

  "
"
"

  





 









 
! 
 


 


 



  4


 



 




  
 


 


   
$ 

 9

 
 " 



 



 "
 " 





  
 "
 
7
"

4 
? @



"




$ 

6 


  

$ 

 
9
$ 
 
 
 







   






 " 

 

 



 

 
 
 
4
 
 



 
"

 


 
 " 




 "



  
 "
 
7
"
 
 
 



"




 


  



5


4 
6  
 
$ 




$ 
 

 
   0*1




"" 
  

 




"




"

B 






 



   

 

  
 

 


  

 
 " 
 

 
"


5


4 
6  
  4



 


 


  
6 

 
 " 




 "


  
 "
 
7
"
 

  
 

 


  

 
 " 
"




  
6 



 



 
"  

"
  


 




  
 


"  


"


  
$ 
 


  
 


B

 
4
  
$ 
 


  

   

 




"" 
  

 

0-,1

#

 "

    


 " 









"







  


$
$ 
 
$ 


"

    
5
 
"
 




   @


 
   



 
 


6 

  



$ 

   


>
  


  
 

 


  


   
$ 
  

 

  
 




  


4
"" 
   $ 


$

 <

C>D
E
F

F

$

   
$ 



 


" 


9  

 
 
  0--1

 

   


# %& '
).-3-)









  
"

$ 

   




"


" 

 

 

   

# %& '
()*3-)

  




"


" 




 

   

 

 
"

" 


 
 
9 





  
 "
 
7
"
#
4 
  0-+1



 

 

 




   

"


 
" 
$ 

 

(
" 
"
 

   

# %&
' ()*3-)


 
$ 
"" 

>

"








" 


 
 
9 
4
   
"



 
 

 








 " 

4 

 
 
 
 "
 
" 
$  0-(1

# 

  
 
   



$ 
   



$


9 

 
 2$