Debasish Banerjee v. Union Of India And 3 ORS.
! " # $%&' ( ) *
" + ,- + .
$ # # / #0 1( $ 2 23 4- + 1
#) ( 5,6
1 78 923 $2 ,,666: :- + #$ 1 . ) ( ;
" +$25<==66< >- + "
'
?# ) . )
( ; " +$2 <==66< ! " #"$ % &&
) '/- 0( ) '/-0-8 0( '()* (#&" '+)*
%,!-. / ! !
+ 3 ( " $%&' # ) ) 3
# 4@-6=-466<0
75%,
3 - + /
" "# "# 3 " 0'5, # ,:-,,-466A 0
75 %4 3 - 6-6,-466= ) * + 3 1* ) . ##- 64-6A-46,, - 2 9 / B1C (
7 # 46,6546,,
7 3 ? # 3# " - " ( " " ( " 7 3 '
1 -- 29 /B1C ( 6<-6A-46,, / "# 0'5,- 6=-6=-46,, 3 (# # # " 3 /
"#0'5:3---,4-6>-46,6>A3 -+ " ) ? 3 ( # " - 2 9 / B1C 7 "- + ) "
" "
( # /
(3 / -
+ ) # ?# " # # "# - 2 9 / B1C- + 0'5, 3 # - 2 9 / B1C # # " ( " - ( " 3 3
# - # ?## 6:-,,-46,,0
75% 3 3 D
!" #"!
$
% & '&(&&& ) * '+, -./ 0
1 * 0 2+' 3-4 5#/
! 0 !
60 !
7
0
7 0 0 & 8 9 $8 0 7 2"( &."
"
-% ,/" !
"!#: :
# ;0<!
% 0 0
%.9=& !& > *
;; $8 * 6?6 :& !&
& 4
@ / 40 0 ',0 * / ' 0 ' & 3& 1 0 ,
1 0 &= 0 " 3 6:-,,-46,, # " 0
75%< 3 3 -+ "" -
=4 ( &#: !
! "A -'7/ % $ B 8 9$84 0 9$8 C0 @ $8 * 6?# ,$4((.8,)+ 28)2.
$D '&3;- / 82 44 + (4>' E( >4, $ 82 $ !"#"!
+ '
% &'&(&&& ) *'+,-./ 0
&= + 6:-,,-46,, # # $ 1 ). " ( " 0
75%< 3 (
" 3 # - /- " # " :@BC ) 0 ,=A # 3 " :@BC )0 ,=A3 ( D 3;& 8
& 0 B
* * -/ FFFFFFFF -/ FFFFFFFF - / FFFFFFFF -/ FFFFFFFF -/
*
0 * 0 * 7 0 7 * 1
7 7 *
1 1
* 1 * 1 *
* 7 8 ' *
G 0
&= + /- ( 35 " (;-B,C
3" 3 0'5: "# # 6,-6<-46,6 0
759%: ( 6=-6=-46,, 3 3/ "# B4C ( ( # ,-6A-46,,
759%@ ( 3 # - 2 9 /B1C( %
"
3 :@BC ) 0 ,=A- +
73 3 -
2 9 / B1C # ?# ,-6=-46,, 3 # ?# 4,-6=-46,, " 3 7 '
?# "- ( ) # # " - 2 9 / B1C # ?# "
7 3 --9 "
7 " ( "# 0'5,-$ ? 3 3 3
/ "# B#C # )+9 * +90 0 46,6 # ?# "( "
3 "#0'5, 3 # "# 6=-6=-46,,-/- " :@BC 18 2 7& -!
# " 3 3 " " 3 3 # # " " - # /-
3G( "H " :@BC ( "-
7 +& H E 7& + & - 6# /! '' ; 63 B &C 3 G H 7 ,4@ -- -$
D 4 I J J0
J
7 0 G 0 00
& > * J J @ K-/ 0 0 * 0
* K-/ * &K * /- 7 +
7& $ -! 6/#'':;
7 ( >> ><>A ><, $ 3 D $ I J*
G
& 4
L 7 7 G * 0 * 1 G &> G 0 0 0 *
&4
*G -0 7 0 0
/ G 5?5 ' & G *
&
* 5?:
5:
' &= 0 ) /-0-8
,=-6A-46,@- ) 9" 6,-6<-46,6 ( 6,-6<-46,6 # 3 3 3 / "# B0'5:C 3--- ,4-6>-46,6 >A3 3 "G # H-/- 8 ( # 3 / "# "# / "( ( / " % 7 -2#(333 ##3/ "# ( -$ 3 / "# ( 3 (33# -3(#(3 ? ( 0/0 (H (# "3
( " - + # .
# ( 3 3 B/ C " " # (3- /- 8 # " / $ " " / 3 " / - 29 /B1C ,-6A-46,, / "#0'5, # " 3/ "# 3 #( 6,-6<-46,6 0
759%, ( 3 3 (# (# -
1 /- 8 3 3 "# ,-6A-46,,#- 29 /B1C
759%@ (- '( 3 "( 7 "-$ "/-8 3 # 2- $10%' %46>%46,6%44>54@ ,:-6A-46,, 3 " 3 "# "
" " " )- ) ,6-6A-46,, / "# # # 0 B'++C $1 ) +90 )+9 " D !& ( &#: !
! "A -'7/ % $ B 90 + ' 3 -4 5#/
&& & !& 5&!
5# 1 0 = 7
& ( 9 $8 C0
,
& 0 * G , 1
!& #&!
% & '( ) * '+, -./& 3&
L*
7 G " ( &#: !
! "A -'7/%$ B 9
* * 0 ,
89 "%'&= I' J ) $ # " "# - 2 9 / B1C
- /- 8 " # # ?# # " @@ )0 ,=A- ( ?# " ?
( 3 ( :@BC -0 (3 7 # # # - $
3 / "# 3" -
29 /B1C3 / "# ,-6A-46,,0
759%@ (-) 9" 3 ( # 6,-6<-46,6 # " 3 / "# B0'5:C 6,-6<-46,6 - /- "
9" " "
- !
? " H 3 " :@BC )0 ,=AK :@BC )0 ,=A( # 3 # (;- # " # # 3 ( "("# 3 3 3 ( (# " " # # # " # " # " # " 3 -+
( G ( "("H # 3 -!
3 7 #-
29 /B1C 3 3/ "#
( "#- 29 /B1C-9
"
7 " "# 0'5,- "# - 2 9 /B1C - +
" :@BC )0 ,=A # H
3 # ,:-6A-46,, "# ,6-6A-46,, "# #- 29 /B1C 64-6A-46,,- $
"# # 3 3 3 ( ( " - # 3 ( 3 6:-,,-46,, 0
75% 3 " 3 0
75%< 3 -$ #
#
# ( 3
( ( 7 "
" 3 -
( 3 "# - + - % 3 /