Babul Ch. Das And ORS v. The State Of Tripura And ORS

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA
AGARTALA W.P.(C)No.427of2014 1. ShriBabulChandraDas, 2. ShriAmarManikDas, 3. ShriUdaiManikDas, 4. ShriSatyaranjanDas, 5. ShriSanjoyDas 




 
 
 
  
 
  
 


  
 



  
 
 

6. Smt.LaxmiRaniDas,


!
 
 

 






"
 





  #

 

7. Smt.SaraswatiDas


$

 




 
% 
  
#
& 
 














.........Petitioners -Versus- 1. TheStateofTripura,   
'

  

() 
* ) 

 

 +' 
 
$
 
 ,

  
& 
 



2. TheDistrictCollector,  
  

"
 
 
3. TheSub:DivisionalMagistrate, 

"
 

  

 

4. ShriRakhalMitra,


 


 
  
 


  
 



  
#
 
 

........Respondents

[2] BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA - 


:


!
 .

!)












(

!)










- 




$ 
/

0
:

.'

 
!
*!

- 




$ 
1
:


!)















+
 +
!)





)

:28.09.2015

2 
"


&





 
 : Yes No √ JUDGMENT&ORDER(ORAL) 3

!
 .
 



  
'


(









.'

 
 
!
*!






$ /4
"
0
 



 


+
 +




1


[2]

 







)  

 

4451/678

 
  
157
 

 


$ 9/4
 
 6:4608
6:4615
6:4607
9;1
9;0:460/
9;0
 
916





( 
 /94148488;47474749
 
4746

 +
 

 
 ) 


 
 
 


  
 
 










50594554
 
 






)


 
!




/15;45/0



1


 






[3] '






( 
 4746



 






 
  
5/8
 
<9
  =



( 
 4746
'






 



$ /

;
 


' 


$ 57

45/1

/85045/1





)
2
2
) 


 
. 
 


 


)





1
>





$ 8
 
7
)
'  




 
 055;45/0



1








4





)
514
 





( 
 4746




'
'

 






3








 
( 
 
 








055;45/0



4
 

)


' () 
 
$ 76

45/0


6;


%(
"
%(
!


/685
!

 ?



'




0
> 
 ?




/55445/1

'
'

 
   


 





455445/1
!

, ;
"
8
 )







'






1

) 


)

 


 



 
 

'+

 





 





1

'


 



5/8
 



/15;45/0
>



 










[4]




((


'




1
 
'



 



 [3] 
!
 .
 




'

 
.




)




4
 





//5845/1

() 
 
$ 76

45/0
  



 
  
5/8
 


( 
 4746





 


'







1
 




 



 
 ) 

 

 


[4]
!

?





'
 




0
 
 

 




 


 

? 


>










0



)  
' 
() 
 
$ 5/

45/1
'



595645/1




  






 
  
5/8
 
 
( 
 4746



 






 

)  
 





. 


4;5645/1

 

'+





0
 


 ,



47/445/1


'

 







)

 



//5845/1
 
'




4

() 
 
$ 76

45/0




 



[5]




 


 

 
/678
'



595645/1
' 
()  
$ 5/

45/1
'




0

[5]

 .
 




'






 

) ' 



//5845/1

'
 )

-   




 .
 




 

 





 
  5/8
  
&




 )





//5845/1
 


)
'  
'

4

 [6] - 





.'

 
 !
*!







$ /4
"
0

'




//5845/1

' 




 ?

'





'



 










.'

 
 
!
*!


'




 
' ? 


 


)  
$ 76

45/0






4



'





 


'









//5845/1


0

 







  

 
/678
' 
)  
$ 
5/

45/1
'



595645/1









[6]



!
 

 



'




  


  
 

+ 


'

! 
448






> 

[7] 




1



 
'

' 

 





 ? 
'




'


  





 

'+



   






'+


+ 
!
 










[8] - 

)




,


'








 
  
? 





'


 
)@A
(i) Whether the revenue court is under any obligationtostaytheproceedingwhenasuitis filed by one of the parties as regards the title and when the dispute before it substantially touchestheissueoftitle. (ii) Whether the civil court has got the jurisdiction to decide the issue of the title in viewthattheverybasisofthetitlebytheorder of allotment was being examined by the authoritywhichmadesuchallotment. [9] >






 
 




) 





) 
 
 










 :



 
 






 )







) 
 

 


 






 )

B 

 


 




[7] 

'


 

  

 
'



)



 

  


) 
  





) 

+  
!
 

)


'


  



//5845/1
 
)






)




 )


3 )

 



.








//5845/1




//5845/1


'+ 


  

)


> )


 




 ) 

 
')   

//5845/1

'




)





 


? 



'


'


 






 ?
'



  

' 
, 
'

 
 
 


 
'

'+ 



' ? 





'


 



'



 

 




)  
>


)


/99


%(
"
%(
!



 )

' 
 )


/99


%(
 
%(
!



 A
188. No suit or other proceeding shall, unless otherwiseexpresslyprovidedinthisAct,lieor be instituted in any civil court with respect to any matter arising under and provided for by thisAct. Providedthatifinadisputebetweenpartiesa questionoftitleisinvolved,acivilsuitmaybe broughtfortheadjudicationofsuchquestion.



[8] [10] !
 

 
'



/99


%(
"
%(
!



'
)

, 


 


 

 







 '





'
 
'


6



)

 



. 








  '



) )

)


3





1

'

'

 

? 


  '














'
'




[11] 3) 





0

 
  

() 
 
$ 5/

45/1




$ 57

45/1

 

!

 




 



, 

 
'

)


'





 


JUDGE