Tripura State Co-Operative Bank Ltd v. Sujit Kr. Roy And ANR

INTHEHIGHCOURTOFTRIPURA
AGARTALA CRL.A.No.20of2014& CRL.A.No.22of2014 CRL.A.No.20of2014 Appellant: TheStateCo!operativeBankLtd., 

  
 
 
 

 
  


 
















 !

 ByAdvocate:








"
 
# 
"
"$"
% 
&
"
"%"
'
( )

Versus Respondents: 1. SriSanjibNath, 
*
+
+  
# ,



 
*
- ''
&
"."
/ 
"+"
 
  


 



2.
TheStateofTripura,  

'



ByAdvocate: 
"
("
0
""

"
+"
%
/ 1
( )



CRL.A.No.22of2014 Appellant: TheStateCo!operativeBankLtd., 

  
 
 
 

 
  


 
















 !

 ByAdvocate:








"
 
# 
"
"$"
% 
&
"
"%"
'
( )

 Versus Respondent: 1. SriSujitKr.Roy, 
*
'
+ 
$"
# 


 
*
 
# 
"+"
 
  


 



2.
TheStateofTripura,  

'



ByAdvocate:  "
("
0
""
"
"$

( )
"
+"
%
/ 1
( )



BEFORE THEHON'BLEMR.JUSTICES.TALAPATRA




*


:22.04.2015



*
'

)
*



:30.04.2015
2  
&
.



3
* 
*
 
: Yes No √ JUDGMENT&ORDER (

'
 
*


,
 
*
4 '

!5"!6"!75

*


'




8#$9
 
0#"
:77
*
!7:
'  


 '




*

7:"!

"!7!
 +  
5!

;5

(;7!

*

""$
 
''

  

  
 


1


*

*

'



,  

 "



 [2]

(*

 '


 
'


+ #,
# ,

+
+


$ 
# 
+
2  1
$1


 ) 
 
+  
5!

;7!

;5

(;7!

*

""$"



 
+



0
+
0'

+  ''
# 
+

'

$  
+
( )
(  1 
+
+, 
%

+
+ , 



 ) 
 
+ 
7!

 / 
+ 
5!


7!

*

""$"


/
  

 4 
*

 )  "
(''

 ) 
* '

'
 
$ '
('
"7!
*
!75
77
*
!75
7
*
!75
7:
*
!75
75
*
!75
7
*
!75
7
*
!75
76
*
!75
7
*
!75

!
*
!75



*

(

'"

+  
2 

 
 


'
/
 

"
(
 
''

'
 

*
 
,  
*

 '


''






''


$ '
('
"7
*
!75
* '
+ , 


$ '
('
"!
*
!75
* ' +
+, 
%"
#



 
, !5"!6"!75


'

4  

  
"7


$ '
('
 "

'
)

* ' 
) 
*

** 
'


 
+
$ )

 1
< "
 
) 

+ 
:


*

$""$"


[3]
"
 
# 
' 
 '
 
*

'' 

 

*

 


'

 

**
 
,



''



 

 



/
*

 

 

  '
 "
 

*
 
 1


) 
*


 '"
*

/

1 



 
/'

1
 
 ) 
*

*


4  


  
 "


/'


*

/


 
"
= 
*
 '
*  

 

, 

/ 



 

, *
/ 

 
$"

[4]

"
+"
%
/ 1
' 
 '
 
*


  

'

/
 
  
 

   
 

"
# 
' 
 '
 
*

'' "
(



"
%
/ 1
' 
 '

'


  '
 ) 

+ 
:


*

""$"

,  
 


 '
'

 '


''  
)   


 
'"
=

*
  
 



 
)

 
 

   

 

'

''







 

,




  "


 
 



'



*


*
 ) 
 


  

/''

 , *  )

*

)

 "
 [5]
=) 



   
*

'   '

/''


 
 
$
*



''




 '
/
 


(

'"
+  
2 

 
 
"
.
5"!

"!75

(

'"
+  
2 

 
 


  '
"
(*
 

 

5"!

"!75

'
/
* >
*
/ 
 

:!"!

"!75"


*
*


:!"!

"!75


/ 
 


* '

 


'
/
* >
*
,  "

$ '
('
"77
*
!!5


/


 ?
Todayallthe10CriminalAppealsbearingNo. Criminal Appeal No. 10 of 2014, Criminal AppealNo.12of2014,CriminalAppealNo.13 of 2014, Criminal Appeal No. 14 of 2014, Criminal Appeal No. 15 of 2014, Criminal AppealNo.17of2014,CriminalAppealNo.18 of 2014, Criminal Appeal No. 19 of 2014, CriminalAppealNo.20of2014,aretakenup forhearing. The prosecution has submitted written argumentsupplyingcopythereoftotheother sides. Fixon19.08.2014forJudgment.

[6]

+ ''



$ '
('
"75
*
!75
7
*
!75

7
*
!75
) 
)

  ''




*
,  
/
* >

7 "!6"!75"






$ '
('
"
7!
*
!75

7:
*
!75
) )

  ''



:!"!

"!75


*
,  
/
* >

!6"!6"!75"
+
*

$ '
('
"7
*
!75

!
*
!75

   


*
,  
/
* >

!5"!6"!75"

/'


 
*

 

:!"!

"!75


(

'"
+  



 2 



 )


*
 

'
/ 
/
 

"


*
) 

 *'


/

,  

,


/

 '
 '




,  
 *

'
* ' *

 

''




 '










,  "
 
 

*''/


  

 
*

'



' )
*

  



"
3

** 
'' '

 


/'


 


 '
 



*
* 


*

 
*


''

 

*


   

** 

 

 


 
*


/ 

 

 
 '
*
)

** "

+ 
!
*

$""$"
)



 ?
If several acts of with one or more than one or by itself or themselves constitute an offence,constitutewhencombinedadifferent offence, the person accused of them may be charged with and tried at one trial for the offence constituted by such acts when combined and for any offence constituted by anyoneormoreofsuchacts.

 [7]

=



/


/
*  
''

'' 
' 
/ 

'' 
/
'






 
*

  
*

** 




 '
/
 "

 '

/
''



'




 '
 


 "



 [8]


 


 
*




  '

*

 

  


)

*''/

''

 



'
 

,  "

 
*

'
*

*
, 

 '

'*
  

''





  
*
,



' 


  
*




'"

 $

 


)



 '
 

 





*
, "
= 

 
,  

 
*
4 '
!5"!6"!75

*




"

'
 $ '
('
"
7
*
!75

$ '
('
"!
*
!75

 




*

+  
2 

 
 
*



''

7!
'

*


,  

>

 '


 '"
 
$


*
) 
 
>
 




 
*

,  
 


'"

 
$



*
,

, 
 



   '


*

'
 
) 

+ 
:


*

$""$"






*



) 
/'

)'


) 


 )
 

* '
'
 

 
*
4 '

*
4
  

  


''
"

' '

*''

 *

/



) 
)



) 

 

*

'
 





 


4  



 ) 
*

'
** 

 4
  

'



'
''
'






/ 

'

 '

'


 

 
*
 ) 
*

"


/ 
@

A
4  



*
 ) 
*

'
** 

 4
  
''

 ' 
)

''

4  

 ) 
*

'
** 



4
   "
*
*


'
'





*

+  

'


) 
*

 
*


''
'





*
+  "
*
*



'
'




= 
$

'


) 
*

 
*


''
'




= 
$"

[9] =) 
'



'
 
''/ "

# 



 /

 
/ 
' "


 JUDGE