Dr. Abhijit Choudhury v. Chinmoy Sen And ANR
!" # $" % $&''
! ( ! ! #(
( !" # $" % $&'' ) %!
% *
#
+
# #
,
%
!" " "#!
"$%& "&
- ' .! + # - * ' .!/ + # - * )' .0 ' + '(
(
%)$" *)"
!# 1&2345
( #6
12)4+ # * *7 8 )1
# . " % 6
% *
9 (
:
; <3 +#5 #6 #6 =# 4)1 #
* (9 ( = :
+
2)1 * + = #6 * &&18 1 < * &&1; ) <
# = # ( #6 ##
( > 7?( =( # #(
2))1
#6 =
##
21)1 =
9 = #
# (
# 35
!# 12 *7#
= * #+
# # * '1)4 % *
(9 ( # ( * # ((
# !# 12 *7# + 7 #
# ## !# ); =
* * ### ##% # + # +# "< #( # ( +# #
#6 (( ( 21)1
#6 # 21)1 #9 =( ##
= ## (
#
21)1 # # 21)1 #9 =( #+
+ 9 ##
* ';1)11; ( !
7 .( # = * # #6 !+ 9 ##
( > 7?( =( # 3@:
5 % * ## #( #
#+# # A +# = * =:( !# 11 #( ( # +# ## # % #
(
( =# =B
!
"
#
" " ! "
!$%%&'
!
#
" (
#
! " "
) # +# #
6 + # # #6 * &&1; &&18 @: ) @: # +
% #
+
= # = ##
* #+ (
# + *
( !
*
" !
"
"
!
* +
" ( " (
#
( # # =
#
= = +# (
# ## # ( # # ! "
# $% !
"
&
"
& "
%
' + ( #
:#
,-* "./0
1234/5526 , 6 = +#
# # ( # 35
!# 12 *7 # #
9 - . ! #
(
+ # #
( # 82)4 + *7 * 8 )1 +
# #
( (
( 7 ( 82)4 # ( = = 3222/553% 1/55% 78$32 4.9(1% 1678$/5 361% 1234/5526 . 7 #
#
# #
+ +# ( (
# #
= # # + + #
+
= # = # # 7 ( ( ( #6
## C(
#+
#A +#
# == (
+#= ( # 35 !# 12 *7# !
#
#
,- * " ./ 0
= :#
B 8
! "
!
*
!
"
"
"
"
! ++
" ! ( !
/ 36 !
7 :!
;+ 5
<
"
"
= *
!
( ) . ! #
+ # # # (
# #
= ( ( 7 # :
#.! #
# : #
> ?
< /< ?
3222/553= :#
+ B 14( / 36!
7
( + ( @ @
/ 1
(
! ( ( "
(
*
(
"
(
( ! '
7
(
"
+ !(
!+ ( ! +
1* %
(
"
(
""
+
<+
! 3
"
5
!/ 36!
7 A!
<+ (
9
+
<
+
( +
8
"
+
(
(
!
"
)
. ! #
## :#
55 7 ;9 .
, ""
1 /55 7 # : #
= # ( +# + !# )& 0 # 2'& !# 4 7 @+# # 2&) 7 55 7 ;9%
:#
=# # + # :
+#
# B ;
!
+
" "< "
%
/ 36!
7 (
" (9
*
/ 36!
7
( :
5 ( !
%
+
!
!
"
! ! " !
"
(<
+ +
!
:
5 %
+ !!
"
!
"
"<
"
!
! "<
"
% "
" ( ! + "7
(
(9
*
(
!
5 ( !
"
5 ( +
'
! <+ / 36!
7 % ++
(
! + "
/ 36!
7 "
"
) 7557 ;9 :#
# -/
?
1 /55 4 # 6 # # =# # 6
= +#
# #
(6
#
# +#7 55 7 ;9 = #
#
= # # = #6 ## !# )& 0 # =
# (# 6 ( 35
!# 12 # # (= #
# ( : # 3#5
!# ( = #6 *+ =
=
#
=
= 9 =
# =
7557 ;9
B 33 ;
!
+ ?
!
5
/
<
! / 334 ! C 7
8 !
"
/ 334 !
C 7 ( +
(
(
"
%
"
"
"
!
! #
!! ! "
(
+
"
! #
( !
"
'
(
+
<
+
% !
+
"
/ 334 ! C 7 31 *
"
+
+
"
!/ 334 !
8 C 7 % 361 !
!
/ 334 !
8 C 7 % 361
! D / 334 ' 5
"
"
B
!
! '*
5
"
"
B
! !
< <
%
+ ( +
"" ! " (
( %
! !
8
*
5
"
"
' ! *
"" ! ( (
!
3 7 + / 334 !
7
!
5
"" !(
((
+
%
5
"
"
+
%
"
"" ! ( !
* % / 334 (
5
"
B
! !
< <
%
+ ( +
"" ! % " (
(
! !
5
"
"" !( (
!
"" ( %/ 334 (
5
"
"" ! %
"" (
!
?
"
/ 1 !
E57 !
+
"
F
/ 334 !C 7
!
+
"
%/ 1
!
!
"
F
<
!
/ 1 !E57
( D 1, +!
( '
5
7 $ + " !
""
"
7
G
"
(
(
(
+
%
% !!
%
(
"
( !!
(
+%
'
+ + (
+
%
+
"
%%
% (
!!
"
(
3 8!
!
!
+
!
"!
(!/ 36 !
7 %
(
5
"
!
/ 1 !
E5 7 / 334 !
C 7 %
%
"
!!
(
8
(
+
(
+
"
"
! !
" ! 5 ( !
/ 36 !
7 "
8
"
"
" (!
+ +
" "
!
8
"
<+ +G
"
/ 36 !
7
5
(
" ! !
/ "
!
"
"
(
"
8
!
(
"
(
!
<
+
( +
"
"
8 %
!
!!
(9
!
/ 36
% "
!
"
"< "
38 ( ( "
"
!++!
!
"
" H
!++! (
! + "
7
"
( %
3 !
! "" !
"
"
/ 36 !
7 % "< "
" ("
5
" "
3 !
!""(
+ "
"" %
"
( (
7
3 !
""!
"
5
+
"
/ 36 !
7 % (
!
/ 36% ( + +
"
/ 1 !
E5 7 / 334 !
C 7 8
%
% !
!
(9
+ 7 (
?
<
% !
++ !
5 (!
"
<
+
""
+
(
+ !!
+
!
"
+ !/ 36 !
7 ) + . ! #
: #
6 # ,-* " ##
9# = :#
557 ;9 #,-* " ./0
# ( : #
#
+#
# #
##
+#
+# +
# # # (
- (
. ! / #
* ## ,- * " # # (
# + = *
* % #
# ( 35 !# 12
# ,# ( ( + 6 =# (( B " = ,- * " # # + ,-* "
# # # : #
557 ;9= =!# 4 @+## 2&)(
# +
# D7 #
(
# (( #
+
# =
+ ( (# !# )& 0 # #+ +
+#(
+(
## *
#
(9 #:# +
#
# :# = # :#
55 7 ;9 =# # ( 7 ( +
7 :# # # + #+
%:#
;
.- ?
?
13 /553 = = ( !# 1'
( + + /
, 7
8
78$ 326 /5 3
#
( + # = #
( 11 8
"
!
( +
"
( +
4!
.
! 5
7 ( <
"
! !
"
!
( 9
++
!+
(
0+
"
+
!( !
!
4
(
1*
9+"
!
"
14 7
"
16!
8"
'
B 7
8"
'
BA!!
5"(
( ( 0
(
5"(
.
F
0 %323D I
875 ! !
%I) ( % #
(
= # 55 7 ;9 #
= :
;
. -
;
.- #
#
: #
55 7 ;9 # 6 # =
# :#
= + # ,-* "@+
# (
# ,-* "= ==+=
(#
!
#( # + #
# = ( (
+# # # :
( #
, 7 55 7 ;9% 6 #
- /
=
(
# +
# !# 12 *7# =#
(
# = (
#
+
# # # @+ 55 7 ;9 .
, ""
: #
,/ , J,/
!>
7 1 /55 2 + # ;
. - ?
?
B 16 (
!!
@, .
"
@% @/ .
"
@ @5 .
!@ (
(
5
: ! 8 :A8 .
" E
- ( H$ D 131/553
! +
"D 8
+
!!
+ I (
"
I I" (
"
I / 41 !
.9( H $ 7 !
"
+
!
" "
(
!
"
+
+
" "
(
E
"
'K'
(
!
"
(
(
(
"
"
I
"
I ( *
"
+ !
I"
"
I I
"
I (
/ 4 !
C 7 % 361% !
"
! (
"
!
+ !
8
" !
%
%
I
"
I (
( "
I
!) 128
"!/ 4 !
C 7
(
7
5
"
! %
+ !
*
@
@@
@ (
! / !
C 7
"
D .
' 7 ! (
% !
+
"
(
5
( B %
B
((
" +
" !
B -
' 7 ! (
% !
+
"
(
5
(
B %
'
B
((
"+
%
" !
B (
!!
!
"
!!
!
(
F ?
!
7
.
;+ 5
E / L
/! M D 78$3267.32 8
9+"
% $% 0 ; H
<+ !
F ?
!
C 7 + "(
+D78$ 34% F "
!
%
!
! !
5
((
"
!!@
( !
!!
"
@
@
!
+
) !
78$
346'42% 1 1 F
!
%
%
"
!
"
"
%
!
(
!!
( !
"
%
(
"
/ 336 ( +
(( ! +
!!;
( " !
!
( +
"
(
*
@
@/ 336 "
!
"
"
( ! " !
(
!
<
5
'
B
!
((
" +
%
" !
B * +
(
!
(
!/ 336 (
(
(
!
( +
((
%
B
"
(
%
"
@
@ F
(
+
( %
!
"
"
! ! A
+
(
(
5
+
+
" !
(( %
( !
(<
!!
+ ( *
!
"
/ 336 +"
!!@
A (
5
"
( !
! "
6 8! !
! + %
!
" +
( "% @!
@
(B
B"
!
;
(
%
(
(
;+ 5
2 7
"
+ ! "
!
"
B
!
! 4 8 . $"
7 @ 7 H H B% % + 2%
" @
"
@ (
!
D 7
"
!
B
! ! < +!
"
< 7
"
!
"
!! ! " ( +!
"
(
! 7
"
(( !
" !
%
(
"
! ! + (
!8 ! %
"
! ! !
! !
"
< I
7??A**% 50% $ ?
% 4 ? N 7 % 2%3 3 *
@.
"
@
"
+ ' !
9+"
#
! "
"
% !
"
< ( ( % "" %
"
! 5 " C 7
"
(( !
"" !
" "
+ *
+
"
!
!
(( %
" !
!
" +
((
+
"
7
"
%
<+%
!
"
<
(
"
!
! !
"
!
" ;+
!!
"
(
"!/ 336 !
7
" !
5
+ @
"
@
/ 32
! 43 8 ;
. - ?
?
D 13 /553 %'0+ ?
5
+ (
!/ 3632 !
7
"
! +
!
"
"
! ! %
(
"
! (! +
"
(
. %0
<+! '0+ ?
% D /55
14'1% 11'1 11 .
"
! !
"
! %( (
%
"
( +
+
(
( ( *
( +
" ( +
"
! !
+
( (
'
B
"
! 1 8
%
!
"
( !
"
! B %
!
(
% (
+
"
"
!
"
(
+
+
7 ! (
% O!
+
"
(
( B %
B
((
" +
" !
B = *
(
(
(
( " ( (
!
"
(
!
B
B
(
(
((
!
( ( +
I
"I 41 *
%
! ( +
%
+
+
" !
"
"
( +
(
"
" ! C
4 8 E . H 5 :
-@/G 7 D1/5511%
(
5
5
"
+
/ 32 !
7 (
(
( +
( !
!
(
"
*
!
!
+
"
!! !
!
"
(
/ 36 !
7 *
+ /
44 8 > H $ " 5 % C
.
% D 78$ 32 3 /5 33 % /(( $% 0%
5 ! 0
%
+
( !
!
" ! / 336 (
+
(
"
(
8!
%
"
"
!!
!
"
"+
+ ! (
!! /
"
!
( !!
(
"
+
/ 336 !
7 +D78$ 332% ?
!
%
( !
! " ( !
(
"
! ! %
"
!
"
!! " (
(
(
" ( (
"
! !
(
(
"
! ) - @+
,/ , J , # + ( (
!# 1' = !# 2 # ( =
( (( #557 ;9 ( #
6 + # ( + = # !# 4 @+## !# )&
0 # =
# = (
+#
#7 6 # 9 HB" 7 13/556 % :#
9# ( +
( !# 1' *7# = !# 235 *7# = =
= ( 3%! %9 5 = ( + 6
= ,/ , J , 7 ,& 79
/
H > E > 78$134/5 :#
+ : + 557 ;9 B
6 * 5
!
/
@
(
(
+ +
* 5
! +
+
!
" /
3 +
!
" ( ( "
"+ +
"
"
" (
! <
(
"
"
!
8 " (
( (
+
"
"
(
8 %!
!
% " "
! !
8!
"
(
<
(
(
+ !
"
" !
!
5
"
! * %
%"
!*
"
" (
! <
(
"
% (
"
(
"
%"
!
<
+
(
*
%
(
'"
+ !
% "
;+ 5
! + !
+ :
/ 461 !
5 ! 5 " .
*
(
!
! ( "
!! (
(!
8
;+ 5
+
9 :
/ 461 !
5 !5 " .
2* 5
"
:
/ 334 !
C 7 :
/ 1 !
E57
"
( "
+
!
! :
/ 36 !
87 *
+
D 3 7 + / 334 !
7
8
!
5
"" !(
((
+
%
5
"
"
+
%
"
"" ! ( !
* % / 334 (
5
"
B
! !
< <
%
+ ( +
"" ! % " (
(
! !
5
"
"" !( (
!
""
( %/ 334 (
5
"
"" ! %
"" (
!
?
"
:
/ 1 !
E57 !
+
"
F
/ 334 !C 7
!
+
"
%/ 1
!
!
"
F
<
!
/ 1 !E57
( D 1, +!
( '
5
7 $ + " !
""
"
7
G
"
(
(
@
@
@+ @ @ @
%
% !!
%
(
"
( !!
(
+%
'
+ +(
+
+
"
% %
% (
!!
"
(
34/ 1 +
"
! (
!!
(
+
8
"
%
+
(
(
+
!
% !
"
!
%
"
(
"
<
+
:
(
%
!
"
(
!!
"
(
! ( * 5
(
+
"
@
! @ @ (
@ @ < @ @ @ @
@%
(
"
P 0+ /+
/+ D32213/55 4#/
! ,. ; A D 322 /55 1 $9>" ./(( "7 D146 /55 4Q 8 %
% "!
"
( :
/ 27 !
7 %
"
:
/ 36 !
7
! (
!
3 8
/ 114 !
C 7
(
5
"
"" ! %
""
(
!
/ 1 !
E57 +
"
! (
!!
(
+
8
"
!
%
"
(
"
<
+
:
(
%
!
"
(
!!
"
(
( C"
337
+
(
! !
% " (
;+ 5
+
"
+
"
:
/ 36 !
8 7
*
;+ 5
+
"
+
!
& "
* "
" "
55 7 ;9%
5
!
"
< /
% (
!
+
!
" /
5
"
! (
"
+ !
"
;+ 5
! + !
+ :
/ 461 !
5 ! 5 " .
*
(
*
;+ 5
@
(
'
0+ ?
/ < * N* " *
/ < * N * + (
! "
B!
8
("8 (
8 55 7 ;9%
"
!
'0+ ?
8 %
9+"
'0+ ?
/ < * N*
! "
) . % #
(
+ =
( +#
#
*7 # + # = !# 1' !# 235 *7 #
!# )& 0 # #
=
( # # +(
<
!( :#
+ = + ( + !# 4 @+##
(# # # + +#7 ##
!
(
= = ,- * " % #
(
( ,- * "% + ( + = # :
= # - /
?
=# # !
(
557 ;9 # (
=
# ,- * "7557 ;9% :#
6 + # ( =!# 4 @+## 2&)
## + # (( #
# #
( # (( #
+ # (( #
#++ " ( !# )& 0 # 2'& # 6 (
!# 4 @+## !# )& 0 # 2'& + ( # #
+# !# =+ # :#
557 ;9
# ,-* "
9# = +# 557 ;9% #
## #
## :#
=
## # ( :( # (
# ( #6 +#
#
# ( + 35 !# 12 *7 # = + * ## = #+ =
% #
+( +
!# )& 0 #
# +@+ # +
!# 4 @+##
( # = #+
#
# * #
*
# ( # +# 7 ( #
# +# +#
( %
( #
#+ = * +
# * =
#=+ % #
#
# = ## = ,+ #
(
(
#9
#
( +
=
- :# ( (
:
# =
+ % #
( = =9 ( # # ( # # ( #
: (
## #= = 7 =
:
# + %)" .