Gopal Ch. Deyand ORS v. Ongc And ORS
!
"#$% & ' ( )
* + ,
"#$% & - (
( ,
.
* , ,
"+$% & / 0&,
( &1& 2) 2
2
"+$% & 3 ( &
4 4 !
( ,
, "+$% & 5 1
4& 4 ( &
( $
"+$% & 6 0 1 0&,
7&( &
.
* +11 ,
"+$% & 8 &
.
* ,
( "+$% &
9
1
1 .
* 7
2
,
"+$% & :4
& & 0 0 ,
& & )
(
"#
.&# % *2 &
4 ;7<
7&
, 2 ;% (
< & '
=4 ;>* <+ >" 2/ *2 &
% (
& - 4 *2 &
, % & * " ( , ?
+699:/ / "; < *2 &
% & ( , ? +2 "+$% &
> @4 ( A,1 )"
4 ( A,1 4
1
4 1 )"
> @4 )"
4 & )"
= * )= & , @ ! $ == @"
(= A = & =
A A=" A=, ,& = )&@+
! " #$!% !" #&'
% ( ) (
* +,"
- ' B "& 4 ( A,1
"& 4 1 =
"& 4 "& 4 & = - " A
" A1&
2 &
;= C2 D< % &
988 989 ),
= )
)A " " "
, 2' -AA1 ) = )) "
2/ 3AA1
& $1 2 5 6 A A1
";44 "< 28 A & 7= , 29 A A1 % "
2:A A1 >A ( "
% =, & =
'3'5 A &
, =" A1A ", '/: & ' ""&) , A &
2 ,= A
=&
"
" = ,, 1 ?&+ % = =
= "
" A1 A &
-::99: A , = A =&
";
?&+ ' A <
, A '3:9999 A 2 4
& A "
A ,, , , = 2 , "; < = 2 =, D &
E " A1,& 4 "&
B"
" A1 ,& "
4 ,1 ?
, % " ; <
=, =
= " = ") = "& "; < =, , A = " A1 A& " ':::+'::
" A1 A
&
" = ,&= , ? ?&+ -
" =
, A +2 $1D A ,& = &"
, 5:/'::: '-:-'::/ ? ?&+ /
?&+ 3 ") 7 ,& = , '-:-'::/ 4 & A
) " A1 A ) &
) "A
&
"=& =
,= " = " A1 A =, &
A
1 A " % " A
-8
" A1 & = , ': A1 A
&
':::! A1 "
& "& " A1 & = , : "F& ,1 "="
, , , 4 ,1 "="
=
&
, = &
':6':/ ;
?&+ 8 A < 7 " + &
), = =
& = & 4 . "
);B.< & 4 . "
) ;$"
< & >, " " ,
= &
,
),A )A ) ,=, &
" = ),2':-+% & , 1
?&+ 97"
"F& F& F&
="
" )" & &
E / " 2- :
A ;
/ &, < = $ ;
< 2':/ = '::9 = & B &
("
1 ,
"
= A A ,% =A
A
A
, % = A =
= & ,
= "
= ) , A &$ ;
<2':/='::9
$
2-'='::9 "
A A" A & A A "
A , A "=
&$
2-'= '::9 " &" &
7
"
A A "
A1
" ), " " A & A ,
A1 % "
= "
,
&
)" )A = "
1 A A
3 = == ) , = " = A " A &
, 1 = " = A A , A 7" ) "F& F& F&
="
&
E & +A1 5 "& 4 ( A,1
" "
A1 A1 =
'3'5 "&& A & 1
) "F& , &
E &
& + 7 "& = &, "&
= ="
, A " = F& = ), ;
?&+ 9< "
?&+ 9 ),, ==
& =
+ 777 = &
& +;
+7.< "" "& 4 ( A,1 = F& ), " "B
A) , = A F& F&
="
= 4 ,1
& , , ) 4 ,1?
,
) ",
= &
& + == & 2 B
" A ,, 2 &
E , 2 % & A F& =" = '- &
E A &"
& " A ) 2 A
"1 , & &
E & + 6 " "& 4 ,
A A "& " "="
A A
= 2-: % =="
& A 8 7 , A "
" A1 988 989 ) A1 &"
"
" A1"&& 7
, , A , ,=2 A1D&= '3:9999 , A = &
" A1 ,&
) F&
="
= ,1 A
& ':::+'::
" A1A
&
E 9
& " " "&, 2 % & A F&
=" ='- = &
=8"
A1 ;
?&+ 5 A <>& ,&= , '-:-'::/;
?&+ 3 A < A 4 & " A1 A ) A
&
) " " A1A
&
E&
"=& =
,= " = : 7 , 2-:
A ? = $ ;
< 2':/ = '::9
=
("
= & B & A A , & , '::'::9 ) = & , =
A@+ ./ *
0 1
0 2
3
.4 .557#8 9
% *
3
2 8 :
3 2
: * 47 .557 #8 6 %
*
*
!
2 -
) = A =$
2-'='::9 )("
=
& B & & , -:':: ,
A =
A @+ G;< 0
*
3 &
3
- '
= A =$ ;
<2':/= '::9 , 1
& "
A
A A =
, , "
& 7 A & =
A A=, ,&A "
A " A &A 1 & ,@+ = >
,)
*
! ? +,"@'
A
*
!
? +,"A
= >
3
?- 7 A
& A "
"& 4( A,1A "="
A
A ,
- " A
" A1 = ), ) )A " && = &"
" = )= ) A = ),
= )A "&"&7 "
= A = &
E , +2 % & A F&
& " '- =
" A1 A "
= 1 A
" 7 =
& "
A " A1 & A &=
A "&, " 7
, F&F&
="
=
, A , A , = " = A A
% ) A ", 4 ,1 ?
, = &
, "
& ) "F& ,1 "="
"
= "
, &
&
" A A
/
" "
A1 "
=
, &
= )" &
& & &"
" , 1 &
= " A1 &
3 & , & "
= #$%#&'%() &'&# "* +'%,'&'-' . "%/ 0 1'2#345 ',2 "%/)
A
A &A "
=
A & F&"= ? & &7 7 /6/8 /9 ? &
=
A@+ 9B &
3 2
) 3 8
) *
: 8
) 3 : ) 3 3 3 9/
+ 494< * )
8 3
3 :
3
: : 3
,
3 3 :
+ *
3
+ 49 4< * :
8
:
: + 49 4< * ) 2
3 :
)
3
*
3
:
)
3
&
3 *
+ 49 4< * - 5 = &
& + F& ?&+ 9
), A & , % = =
&
,
" & A " A "
" 7=
=&& ) " & + )" = 2 &
= &
1 "
" )
"F& F& F&
="
% A1 =
'3'5 A & 1 & 1 ) && ,= &
E ,"
= =&&) " & + 6 $ ) A =