High Court of TripuraWP(C)/519/2014allowed

Dipankar Saha v. The State Of Tripura And ORS

2015-05-08Hon'Ble Mr. Justice S. Talapatra11 pages

! "

# $%& ! "' " & (! # '! ) * #'+ (,( +( *! -(#!(#./

"(+(."( % 0000000(( .1".

(( %! " (',*( + #+(*( ( 2 %! (& + #3'%+( ! 4 (# & #5!-$% 6, !(#! "( % (( 6+( +( ! ," 2* !6*7"" ! %! -#'+(( & #5! % '!(#! "( % 00000"

8 ( ! 7 $9"4"!'2 +( 8 ( "

(" ! 7 76%&'!

( !

( 6%'& (: ' ! " ( ( ( ! # $ # 9* & " ( " 4( ! ( " + ## '( && '%&% ' 8

;< <3== ;9=

/<> '(' !

5%<> ( ( 4( !

4 ,* ( " , '" ' " )% 3 ! 6*7"" ! %4 ,*( (( 6+(

+( !( "

( 8 & , ' ( "' && '%& '(' !

5%<> ( ( 4( ! ( 4 %#' 5 "( ( ( ( "' ' '" (" (#*,"' ( ## 4 ,"2( ?

% @( " (, ' ',* ( ( (4 4" 2 %( 5( " ( % " "2+ ( & ( " ,* ( && '%& 8

;< <3== ;9=;A;< '(' !

5%< ( ( 4( ! 4" ( '' 4( "(+( " ( ( " ( , &%+ & +(2! & ( ' " %" '"+ '%(* ' " ( & 2 " 2###2# + '

+ +* 32 ( % ( &(( ##" ( + (+(%# #&! ( " %( " %#' , # ( 5+" (" 4 % ' (+# > ( "((%( @ ' 24 ( '+" " ( 5 + %( !" " # (' $%&'($) ##&*&!+ ,- (' ,.+ $%&& # $/%0 + 1

+2 (' ,.+$%&0 #'/! 3

(' ,.+$%45 #$5*& '& *& ((*2"@ ( ( # (%( (* @ ' ' ( " (' ,.+$%&% #$0649%(( #4 " ( (" 4(6+( * ( + %" (&@( # 4"( ( +"" 4 ( '+" & %( (*5+'"(""((%( * 4 + &&(" ,+ + #" (%# 6%"(+ 5+" (

4 2 ( '+" 4 + " 2" ""' ( #&

!( " %( " (( (2 ( 2 (( + (+(" (',(4 ( (" '( 2 ( '(" +" @ ( " '! 4 &* '2( ( ( '+" " 5 + %( - 3

7 (' $%4%(*) ##6%*! 3 , . # (' $%%5)* ##&'6 '8

9 :7 (' ,.+ $%%$ # '*& 4 ( ,+ + (+( 2 #2' ,+ "((%( * ,#( ' 4 ( ' + & # ' 4" 5+" "((%( * 432 ( % +%" +( "" %(

+ (+( ,%( ( ( " ( , ( '"

%( ( "

%,#+ #4 8 "" +( ,* ( (( " #'

% '& (#!+ "((%( # + #( (( ((+( &%"(,

& ( 2+ ,( "" 2 ( &* ( ( ,%" ""4( *, '*,%("%+ ( "+( ""%,6+(( ( + '( "

,# "" #* " 4## " ( %,#+ ("(

;

( ( " 4 &,(! 7 $ 9"4"! # ' + % "#

( " ( ( " %( ( ( "" ( + ( 2"* 4" ' " ( )% 3 ! '<@ ( (( 6+( -

+ 6* 7"" ! % ,* ( && '%& % ' 8

;< < 3== ;9=;A < / '(' A ;!

5%< ( ( 4( @(

"( (( (

' ( "#+(

+"" ' 4" '"( )% 3 !'<@ ( "'

+ 5' & ( #* &% ( " !

A>=<

' * "' ( 4" "%,6+( ( ( + '( " (#( (( (" ##, #* * +""( &&!4 + 2"# "

" " '" ##,(& (' &( (%( &(+##*

5 * ( % * @ +" % "("

+( *

+'% ( "(*!( "

"" '" ##, (& ('4(

'*" (+ '( (" ## +

* ( ( "

"( +#& %#& # *& ( 3'%+( + # (& ( * ( (& (" (( 2 ( & ( 5 * ( (# ( % *! (

4" 2 ( & ( "B 5( " ,* ( "' && '%& '(' !

5%< ( ( 4( ! 4( ( ( " ( , &%+ & +(2 ' " %" '%(* (!,*( & % '&& '%&'(' ""2+ ", (& ('

' 7 9"4"! # ' + % "# " + ( '' ( ( ( (" ( " ##, * +""(

( &&! 4 + 2 " # ,%( ( "

,(#* ' 5( '' ( ( % #* ( & ( " ((+ " & " '2( ( "( '' +'% ' ( ( ( ,"" % (' """"&

+ '

+ +* " , '" ' C2 ' ( && '%& 8

A< < 3== = A<'(';> !

5%</( ( 4(

!79"4"!# '+ % "# "+ ( ''( (( %

#&( " %"%##* > *" 8 % " +! ( " + ( ' ( && '%& '(' ;> " '%+' % '?

;

,+23 , "

05( ")

, -

" 7 9"4"! # ' + % "# " %' ( ( ( "

( 2 #( ( "(( "( "( + 5( '' ( "2+ ( & ( " ( (4( %( *""""& (4 (" 2!( % ( ",

" 4 ( ( ( + '

+ +* '% ( ( ( % " , """"' 4 '" ' ( ' ( %" " , % ( ,% ( ' ( ( + * % ' , ( 79"4"!# '+ % "# ""%,&(('( (( ' , (+ "%+ (& ( ' ( "' (& ( " , &'"#

"(& (

+ +* ( " +( "%

"( 2+ ,( "" '""%+ 2 ( % ( (" ( + (+(%##&!( " %(&* ( ( +( ( "

"%,"( (#6%"(+ 7 76%&'! # '

( "

(" ""%,&(('( (( (4" #* * '( ( " (+

' * (( ( ( +#& %#

(& ( * 2 ( ' (& ( @ (&" ( + '( "((+ '( ( (! 5 * * "%+ ( " ## %( &(+##* + & ( '

4" 42 ## 4' ( & ( " 5( " + ' " & ,"2( ' '( " +9%( ( ( & ( " 4 ( "

( """"' "

+( ""% +'( (( " (& 2' "

+ ( ## 7 (( 76%&'! # ' " +( +##* "%,&((' ( ( ( 5"(" 2" ( ( ( ( " ## & '( #* , * (! 7

(( 76%&'! # ' " ' ( ( + % (

'2(

#',*( "

("4 ( ", & (+##*+ ( '' "% '?

0% -

& ($5<)

- 2

65$* $ 65$/)

= $$$0< (** ) 6%'' -

7 (( 76%&'! # ' " , % ( ( (

(+ ( %(( (! 4 + " ' ! +#%'"# (" +(2("# ( # !"(&( '4 D%' &%#(

%# # '9%'( !+* %(%# "

+( "+ #" "% 2" ( + 4 "! ( ( (,"' 2 %"(&! +(2(*<4" ,"2( 4( "

+ + "%"( !

"#! &"%" ( 2+ & # "" ' ' +(" ' ( ""% "%D%#(*+ !+ ##+( '+ & #( #'#2#

"" ("! ( #(("=&& "( #' % +( "

( % = ## 4<% +( " ( 5 '( + 4 4( ""%' D%#(*! E &( "=4 "

" 4( ( #' " ( + ( + +(* " 24"='"!

( ' % '( '(<," "+ #

"(%+(%!

( '"%,&"" ((#2# "" (,"'

#' "" (! ( # + # 2# # " 3 +(! ! 2' (+ +# %' + ( #' " ' & #& (

+"! (

%# # ' 9%'( D%& & 2& "+ #

"(%+(% (+ 9%( ( B"

+ 4" (#* #+'"+# ' " ( ( % +' %( "+ # "

+( #* ;; '*" %(

'*" C (( '' (

+ #*

> + ( 4 '*" "

(( ( 4"2 "

+ & 2& " +,%( ''

# '( ( 4"'" ',*( & % ' '7

(( 76%&'! # ' " + ( '' ( ( ( " ,( "" " ##' +"" '+" & '" ( @ 6 ' ( ( + % (

'2( #' ,* ( "

("! ( " ' ' ( ( ( & %(( " , + & ( (! " + , %# (( ' +" ,"' + '" C " %( "%,&((' ( ( 4" %##* (( ' (

+ C " " % ( ( + & " + 4( 6% &#* &"( " '++ ' ( & +" + & '! ( 4 %#'

( ( " + (,%( " &%+ & ( ( "' 6%

" %( "%,&(('( ( &( + '"!(4 %#',

(( ( "+ & #'##( " 2"( '( ' , # " C " #' ,%# ' +%& (" 4( " 6 ' %"# ( " %( "%

( " #'+(2(" 9* ( ' '(' A

! 7 (( 76%&'! # ' 4" '+(' ( '%+ ( "

# + '"

" 4 " &" 2

' ( && '%& '('

/ !

5' ( ( 6 ' #' ,* (

++ ' #* 7 (( 76%&'! # ' " '%+' ( " + '"

- "+%( * ( + '"!(" % '( ( & "( ( " + '" ( 2* &(# '(& ( + ( 2"* 9%( ( " %( " + & + "" ( , ( / % ' 8# 8

A< 3== ; 4 & ( ( "

"( ( + & # (4"&' "(( @(" D% (' % '? !

, -

- ,

! - "

- - -

"' ( '('

" 2(' +( +( ' ++ ' ( ( + %( " , ( + '" ( % - ( % "+%( * ( + '"!( " %(' "

' * ( &( "

( ( ( """""'(

+ ( ' & ( """('( ( 4" (2 * " 4+%"( *#2 (& '"%+ '" % (( 2, +'',*'% (+ ( (! + '" 2#,# ( ( ( ' , * """"& +

+ +* ( (##5+ (( , 2+ '' (

6% !4 ", ( "&' '' " + && ' * "% 2" * %( (* 2 ( "2+"

C +!( " %( "2*"

( ,"2( (( '+" '" ( 4" """"&

+ +* +! ,%( & (' ,* ( "' ( %"! ( & % ' ' '(' !

5%<> ( ( 4(

! " ( ' 4( 8 """"& B"

+ % (( 2, &',*( + & ( (%( (*

% " 5( " " ( % + ( 5( '' ( % "5 '!("'+('( (( + #+(*! (&

3'%+( + #3'%+( ( ( 2 %" ##

##* & """"& + '

+ +* ( '(& 4 ( " ( ( "(

)% 3 (

+ ( %7"" 4 %#', 5( '' 4' @ ( " % + & (2 """"& #* , + & ( ( ( B" + " "("

+( *! ( (2 (( " ##, ' " (& &* , 5( '' " 5+" " ( , + & #(' 4(

& ( &( '*4 ( " ## % " + * ( " ' ( ( + # +(*! (& 3'%+( ! 2 %!(# @("( , (' ( (( " %( " (+ "'' ( ,6+( "', %(( ( % 5( " , #""(

* ,2 %" "

( ( ( " ++ (' ( ( && '%& '(' !

5%< ( ( 4( 4( %( * #%(( ' 4 ' (## ( & % ' ' " , ""%' & C2 #'" !( 4( "( '"## 4'( ( 5( (" '+(', 2C 42!( " ##, '"( + "(" + '" " '%+' ,* 7 76%&'! # ',(% ' # 79