Reba Khatun v. State Of West Bengal &ORS

01-202.

06.01.2023.

Ct. No. 11.

F.B.

MAT/1594/2018 [ASSIGNED] WEST BENGAL BOARD OF PRIMARY EDUATION & ORS.

PRATIVA MONDAL IA NO: CAN/1/2019(Old No:CAN/5471/2019), CAN/3/2019(Old No:CAN/8274/2019), CAN/4/2021, CAN/5/2021, CAN/6/2022, CAN/7/2022, CAN/8/2022, CAN/9/2022, CAN/10/2022, CAN/11/2022, CAN/12/2022, CAN/13/2022, CAN/14/2022, CAN/15/2022, CAN/16/2022, CAN/17/2022, CAN/18/2022, CAN/19/2022, CAN/20/2022, CAN/21/2022, CAN/22/2022, CAN/23/2022, CAN/24/2022, CAN/25/2022, CAN/26/2022, CAN/27/2022, CAN/28/2022, CAN/29/2022, CAN/30/2022, CAN/31/2022, CAN/32/2022, CAN/33/2022, CAN/34/2022, CAN/35/2022, CAN/36/2022, CAN/37/2022, CAN/38/2022, CAN/39/2022, CAN/40/2022, CAN/41/2022, CAN/42/2022, CAN/43/2022, CAN/44/2022, CAN/45/2022, CAN/46/2022, CAN/47/2022, CAN/48/2022, CAN/49/2022, CAN/50/2022, CAN/51/2022, CAN/52/2022, CAN/53/2022, CAN/54/2022, CAN/55/2022, CAN/56/2022, CAN/57/2022, CAN/58/2022, CAN/59/2022, CAN/60/2022, CAN/61/2022, CAN/62/2022, CAN/63/2022, CAN/64/2022, CAN/65/2022, CAN/66/2022, CAN/67/2022, CAN/68/2022, CAN/69/2022, CAN/70/2022, CAN/71/2023, CAN/72/2023, CAN/73/2023, CAN/74/2023, CAN/75/2023, CAN/76/2023, CAN/77/2023 MAT/953/2021 WEST BENGAL BOARD OF PRIMARY EDUCATION AND ORS PAYEL BAG AND ORS MAT/999/2021 WASIM AKRAM MONDAL AND ORS

IA NO: CAN/1/2021, CAN/2/2021 WPA/10005/2021 SRIMONTA PAL AND ORS.

WPA/10304/2019 GOLAM MOSTAFA With WPA/10306/2019 SUMANA DEY WPA/10308/2019 MUNMUN GHOSH WPA/1053/2022 SUTAPA ROY AND OTHERS WPA/10540/2019 TAPAS MONDAL WPA/10541/2019 TARIT GHOSH WPA/10543/2019 RAJESH MONDAL STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS WPA/10800/2019 SHIBNATH KUMBHAKAR WPA/10803/2019 SHAFIKUL ISLAM SEKH

WPA/10909/2018 SOURAV ROY WPA/10954/2021 SUSANTA BETAL AND ORS STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/10956/2019 KUMARI ASTHA WPA/10958/2021 NABAKANTA SASMAL AND ORS WPA/1099/2021 MIHIR DAS STATE OF WEST BENGAL WPA/11001/2019 ANOWAR HOSSAIN WPA/11002/2019 ANUP SAHOO WPA/11003/2019 MD. SALIM SEIKH WPA/11004/2019 SANTANU PATRA WPA/1125/2021 MD TANMIR AHMED AND ORS WPA/11433/2020

SATYAJIT DAS THAKUR AND ORS WPA/11701/2019 PRADIPTA SAHA WPA/11702/2019 KAMAL MANDAL WPA/12021/2019 ARIFUL ISLAM WPA/13016/2019 MD. SABIR SK.

WPA/1316/2022 SRIKUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY AND ANR WPA/1353/2020 KHOKAN DAS & ORS WPA/1396/2021 PRIYANKA BANDYOPADHYAY AND ORS WPA/14722/2021 RAMA BISWAS STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR WPA/14728/2021 ANKITA DEY STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR WPA/14736/2021 LIPIKA GHOSH

STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ANR WPA/16242/2019 RAJ KUMAR DEY WPA/16244/2019 ABDUL ALIM WPA/164/2022 ANUARUL HOQUE WPA/16436/2018 NIRABUL HOSSAIN WPA/16438/2018 SHREYA CHAKRABORTY WPA/16440/2018 SATHI MAJHI WPA/16448/2018 RAKHI CHOUDHURY WPA/16449/2018 BINITA RAY CHAUDHURI WPA/16536/2021 ATIUR AND ORS WPA/16598/2019 TAPAS RAKSHIT & ORS WPA/17003/2019

MARJINA KHATUN WPA/17009/2018 ASHIS KUNDU & ANR WPA/17018/2018 BACCHU SAIKH & ANR WPA/17024/2018 MOHAMMAD ALI WPA/17025/2018 SAMIM BEGUM WPA/1704/2021 BAPAN BANERJEE WPA/1729/2022 RANU SULTANA WPA/1732/2022 RUNA RUKSENA PARVIN WPA/17406/2019 PAMPA BISWAS STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS With WPA/17408/2019 UTPAL MARJIT STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS WPA/17619/2018 DEBABRATA HALDER

WPA/17749/2018 PRADIP KUMAR MAITY & ORS WPA/17944/2019 MD. JAMALUDDIN SAIKH @ SK.

WPA/18329/2021 ANAMIKA CHOUDHURY AND OTHERS WPA/18370/2019 SUJATA KHAN & ORS With WPA/18865/2018 SOMNATH NANDY & ANR WPA/18880/2021 MURSHID ALAM MOLLA AND ANR With WPA/19052/2019 ROSHNARA KHATUN With WPA/19087/2019 SUJIT MAHATA IA NO: CAN/1/2020 WPA/1940/2021 ASGAR SK AND OTHERS IA NO: CAN/1/2022 WPA/19432/2019 MD MAINUL SK

WPA/19607/2018 DALIA KHATUN STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/19608/2018 SUMIT GHOSH STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/19672/2019 DILDAR HOSSAIN IA NO: CAN/1/2020 WPA/1971/2021 SITAL RAJAK AND ORS WPA/19733/2018 KAMLA HOSSEN MONDAL WPA/1991/2021 BIPUL SARKAR AND OTHERS With WPA/20132/2018 RUNA GHOSH & ORS With WPA/20219/2019 DIPAK MONDAL & ORS WPA/202/2022 DEBASHREE DEY AND ORS WPA/20227/2019 DEBASISH MUKHERJEE

With WPA/20246/2018 SRIMANTA DE & ORS WPA/20249/2018 SURUCHI SAHA & ORS WPA/20251/2018 CHANDAN NANDI WPA/20253/2018 RAGHUNATH BANERJEE & ORS With WPA/20255/2018 SUBRATA CHOUDHURY With WPA/20257/2018 RATAN KARMAKAR WPA/20258/2018 SUDIPTA DAS With WPA/20260/2018 RINKU BARMAN With WPA/20262/2018 ABDUL NASIM MONDAL With WPA/20263/2018 PULAK BARMAN WPA/20264/2018 HOSSEN ALI

WPA/20265/2018 BABOR SK WPA/20314/2018 PRIYANKA BHATTACHARYA STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/20317/2018 TANVI AZMI STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/20332/2019 ISMAIL JABIULLAH WPA/20341/2019 MANIRUL HOQUE With WPA/204/2021 DIBYENDU NANDI AND ORS WPA/204/2022 MD ANGUR ALI AND ORS With WPA/20422/2018 SK. ALKAS ALI WPA/20425/2018 PRIYANKA KONAR With WPA/20484/2018 SONAMONI SARKAR & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With

WPA/20495/2018 TARAK NATH KUNDU & ORS With WPA/20642/2021 SHILPI MALAKAR With WPA/2097/2022 MD. ILIAS WPA/20987/2019 DALIA BHATTACHARJEE & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/20988/2019 ARJINA KHATUN & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/20989/2019 SUDEV CH. SARKAR & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/20990/2019 SAJJAK ALAM & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/20991/2019 KUNAL ROY & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

WPA/21191/2018 LIPIKA SAHA With WPA/21398/2018 MONIMALA JANA & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/21407/2018 SUDIP GHOSH

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/21411/2018 AYESHA KHATUN & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/21531/2018 MIRZA ALIUL AZIM & ANR.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/21649/2018 KANU BALLAV ADHIKARI WPA/21650/2018 BUDDHADEV JANA With WPA/21717/2019 JOYDEV KUNDU With WPA/21725/2018 NUPUR SAMANTA WPA/21751/2019 MOUMITA DEBNATH & ORS WPA/21766/2018 SOUGATA MUKHERJEE & ORS With WPA/21859/2018 BIDHAN MANDAL & ORS.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/219/2021 BEAUTY GHOSH With WPA/22274/2018

SAHAJAN ALI & ORS WPA/2245/2021 MD. ABDUL KAYUM AND ORS THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS With WPA/22507/2018 MD. AKID JAVED & ORS With WPA/22701/2019 MD. WASHIM AKRAM WPA/22732/2018 TANUSHRI MAHATO IA NO: CAN/1/2020 WPA/22848/2018 TAJUDDIN AHMED & ANR WPA/229/2021 KAZI MOFIJUL ISLAM AND ORS With WPA/22962/2018 CHAITALI DEY WPA/22998/2018 SAJID AHMED & ORS With WPA/23013/2018 TATHAGATA NANDY & ORS WPA/23016/2018 SAHIDA BANU

STATE OF W.B. & ORS WPA/23122/2018 ATASHI DUTTA STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS WPA/23129/2018 JAYASHREE DE STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS WPA/23132/2018 SANJUKTA SARKAR STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS WPA/23141/2018 PINKEY DEY STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS With WPA/23353/2018 MONONJIT SARKAR WPA/23609/2019 PRADIP SAU & ORS With WPA/24496/2018 SABINA KHATUN & ORS WPA/24499/2018 SUDIP KUMAR GHOSH & ORS With WPA/24520/2018 TARUN MAHATA & ORS With WPA/24522/2018 RAMIZ AHMED & ORS

WPA/24523/2018 MUNSEHWAR CHOUDHURY & ORS WPA/24556/2018 LUTFAR RAHAMAN & ORS With WPA/2460/2018 TAMALI DATTA ROY With WPA/2469/2021 MIR JASMINA AND ORS IA NO: CAN/1/2022 WPA/24917/2018 ASHOK KUMAR MAITY WPA/24919/2018 APURBA KUMAR MAL WPA/24986/2018 BIBHAS MANDAL STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/25180/2018 SONALI SADHAK STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS WPA/25374/2018 PIYALI PAKHIRA With WPA/25375/2018 GOUTAM MOUR WPA/25376/2018 MITHU GHOSH(MOUR)

With WPA/25502/2018 LABANYAMOY GHOSH WPA/26065/2018 A.I. MEHEDI HASSAN With WPA/26067/2018 SAMIM MEHEDI HASAN With WPA/26069/2018 DIBYENDU BHUIN WPA/26071/2018 NASERIN RAHAMAN & ORS With WPA/26076/2018 MANTU PARAMANIK WPA/26078/2018 SK. ANIRUDDHA & ORS WPA/26084/2018 GAUTAM BARMAN & ORS With WPA/26146/2018 KAZI MD MOHSIN & ORS STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS IA NO: CAN/1/2022 WPA/2628/2021 BAPI DAS AND ORS

WPA/26317/2018 SAIFUDDIN SK With WPA/26320/2018 SANTOSH MALIK & ORS WPA/2719/2021 PARAMA GHOSH With WPA/2800/2019 SHIB SANKAR PAL& ORS STATE OF WEST BENGAL& ORS WPA/2802/2021 SUMITRA BHUNIA WPA/2811/2019 REBA KHATUN STATE OF WEST BENGAL &ORS With WPA/300/2021 BAMA CHARAN SATPATI With WPA/303/2021 TAPAS KUMR JANA WPA/307/2021 DIPANKAR PATRA WPA/310/2021 SUBHAJIT SUTRADHAR With WPA/3121/2021 TUMPA NAYAK

With WPA/314/2019 ALOKE SARKAR WPA/348/2022 FARHANA ISLAM AND ORS With WPA/350/2022 SAHIUR RAHAMAN MIDDHYA AND ORS With WPA/351/2022 SUKUR MOHAMMAD AND ORS WPA/4083/2021 CHUMKI MANDAL AND ORS WPA/4414/2021 NAJEM HOSSAIN AND ORS IA NO: CAN/1/2022 With WPA/4451/2019 DIPAK JANA With WPA/4903/2019 RIPON SK.

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.

With WPA/4920/2021 NARGIS AKTAR BANU AND ORS With WPA/4954/2020 KATHAKALI MANDAL (GHOSH)

With WPA/4955/2020 PALASH MANDAL WPA/5482/2021 ALI REZA SHAIKH AND ORS With WPA/5550/2021 MASUD KARIM AND ORS WPA/5584/2022 MD NASIMUL GANI AND ORS WPA/5663/2021 TANMAY GHOSH With WPA/6158/2022 PRASANTA DEBNATH AND ORS With WPA/6291/2021 DEBASIS ROY With WPA/668/2021 MAHENUR KHATUN AND OTHERS With WPA/685/2021 SUBHAS GHOSH AND OTHERS WPA/689/2022 SAIKAT GANGULY AND ANR WPA/738/2021

KOUSIK JANA AND OTHERS With WPA/7809/2019 BASIR AHMED IA NO: CAN/39/2019(Old No:CAN/10172/2019), CAN/54/2019(Old No:CAN/10552/2019), CAN/55/2019(Old No:CAN/10564/2019), CAN/68/2019(Old No:CAN/10734/2019), CAN/73/2019(Old No:CAN/10866/2019), CAN/74/2019(Old No:CAN/11884/2019), CAN/75/2020(Old No:CAN/2535/2020), CAN/76/2020(Old No:CAN/2536/2020), CAN/77/2020(Old No:CAN/2537/2020), CAN/78/2020(Old No:CAN/2881/2020), CAN/79/2020, CAN/80/2020, CAN/81/2020, CAN/82/2021, CAN/83/2021, CAN/84/2021, CAN/85/2021, CAN/86/2021, CAN/87/2021, CAN/88/2022, CAN/89/2022, CAN/90/2022, CAN/91/2022, CAN/92/2022, CAN/93/2022, CAN/94/2022, CAN/95/2022, CAN/96/2022, CAN/97/2022, CAN/98/2022, CAN/99/2022, CAN/100/2022, CAN/101/2022, CAN/102/2022, CAN/103/2022, CAN/104/2022, CAN/105/2022, CAN/106/2022, CAN/107/2022, CAN/108/2022, CAN/109/2022, CAN/110/2022, CAN/111/2022, CAN/112/2022, CAN/113/2022, CAN/114/2022, CAN/115/2022, CAN/116/2022, CAN/117/2022, CAN/118/2022, CAN/119/2022, CAN/120/2022, CAN/121/2022, CAN/122/2022, CAN/123/2022, CAN/124/2022, CAN/125/2022, CAN/126/2022, CAN/127/2022, CAN/128/2022, CAN/129/2022, CAN/130/2022, CAN/131/2022, CAN/132/2022, CAN/133/2022, CAN/134/2022, CAN/135/2022, CAN/136/2022, CAN/137/2022, CAN/138/2022, CAN/139/2022, CAN/140/2022, CAN/141/2022, CAN/142/2022, CAN/143/2022, CAN/144/2022, CAN/145/2022, CAN/146/2022, CAN/147/2022, CAN/148/2022, CAN/149/2022, CAN/150/2022, CAN/151/2022, CAN/152/2022, CAN/153/2022, CAN/154/2022, CAN/155/2022, CAN/156/2022, CAN/157/2022, CAN/158/2022,

CAN/159/2022, CAN/160/2022, CAN/161/2022, CAN/162/2022, CAN/163/2022, CAN/164/2022, CAN/165/2022, CAN/166/2022, CAN/167/2022, CAN/168/2022, CAN/169/2022, CAN/170/2022, CAN/171/2022, CAN/172/2022, CAN/173/2022, CAN/174/2022, CAN/175/2022, CAN/176/2022, CAN/177/2022, CAN/178/2022, CAN/179/2022, CAN/180/2022, CAN/181/2022, CAN/182/2022, CAN/183/2022, CAN/184/2022, CAN/185/2022, CAN/186/2022, CAN/187/2022, CAN/188/2022, CAN/189/2022, CAN/190/2022, CAN/191/2022, CAN/192/2022, CAN/193/2022, CAN/194/2022, CAN/195/2022, CAN/196/2023, CAN/197/2023, CAN/198/2023, CAN/199/2023, CAN/200/2023, CAN/201/2023, CAN/202/2023 IA NO: CAN/39/2019(Old No:CAN/10172/2019), CAN/54/2019(Old No:CAN/10552/2019), CAN/55/2019(Old No:CAN/10564/2019), CAN/68/2019(Old No:CAN/10734/2019), CAN/73/2019(Old No:CAN/10866/2019), CAN/74/2019(Old No:CAN/11884/2019), CAN/75/2020(Old No:CAN/2535/2020), CAN/76/2020(Old No:CAN/2536/2020), CAN/77/2020(Old No:CAN/2537/2020), CAN/78/2020(Old No:CAN/2881/2020), CAN/79/2020, CAN/80/2020, CAN/81/2020, CAN/82/2021, CAN/83/2021, CAN/84/2021, CAN/85/2021, CAN/86/2021, CAN/87/2021, CAN/88/2022, CAN/89/2022, CAN/90/2022, CAN/91/2022, CAN/92/2022, CAN/93/2022, CAN/94/2022, CAN/95/2022, CAN/96/2022, CAN/97/2022, CAN/98/2022, CAN/99/2022, CAN/100/2022, CAN/101/2022, CAN/102/2022, CAN/103/2022, CAN/104/2022, CAN/105/2022, CAN/106/2022, CAN/107/2022, CAN/108/2022, CAN/109/2022, CAN/110/2022, CAN/111/2022, CAN/112/2022, CAN/113/2022, CAN/114/2022, CAN/115/2022, CAN/116/2022, CAN/117/2022, CAN/118/2022, CAN/119/2022, CAN/120/2022, CAN/121/2022, CAN/122/2022, CAN/123/2022, CAN/124/2022, CAN/125/2022, CAN/126/2022, CAN/127/2022, CAN/128/2022, CAN/129/2022, CAN/130/2022,

CAN/131/2022, CAN/132/2022, CAN/133/2022, CAN/134/2022, CAN/135/2022, CAN/136/2022, CAN/137/2022, CAN/138/2022, CAN/139/2022, CAN/140/2022, CAN/141/2022, CAN/142/2022, CAN/143/2022, CAN/144/2022, CAN/145/2022, CAN/146/2022, CAN/147/2022, CAN/148/2022, CAN/149/2022, CAN/150/2022, CAN/151/2022, CAN/152/2022, CAN/153/2022, CAN/154/2022, CAN/155/2022, CAN/156/2022, CAN/157/2022, CAN/158/2022, CAN/159/2022, CAN/160/2022, CAN/161/2022, CAN/162/2022, CAN/163/2022, CAN/164/2022, CAN/165/2022, CAN/166/2022, CAN/167/2022, CAN/168/2022, CAN/169/2022, CAN/170/2022, CAN/171/2022, CAN/172/2022, CAN/173/2022, CAN/174/2022, CAN/175/2022, CAN/176/2022, CAN/177/2022, CAN/178/2022, CAN/179/2022, CAN/180/2022, CAN/181/2022, CAN/182/2022, CAN/183/2022, CAN/184/2022, CAN/185/2022, CAN/186/2022, CAN/187/2022, CAN/188/2022, CAN/189/2022, CAN/190/2022, CAN/191/2022, CAN/192/2022, CAN/193/2022, CAN/194/2022, CAN/195/2022, CAN/196/2023, CAN/197/2023, CAN/198/2023, CAN/199/2023, CAN/200/2023, CAN/201/2023, CAN/202/2023 With WPA/7988/2021 RENUKA DAS AND ORS WPA/8028/2022 KARTIK PRAMANIK AND ORS WPA/816/2021 NITAI MANDAL AND ORS With WPA/824/2021 SHAMIM RAHAMAN AND ORS WPA/8290/2019

LILABATI DEY With WPA/8613/2019 JAKIR HOSSAIN With WPA/8614/2019 JOSHEF REJA SK.

WPA/8889/2021 ELIUS HASAN AND ORS.

With WPA/9188/2021 BASIRUDDIN AND ORS WPA/9947/2019 GOUTAM KOTAL Mr. Lakhi Kumar Gupta Mr. Subir Sanyal Mr. Saikat Banerjee Mr. K. Chowdhury Mr. Ratul Biswas ........ for the appellants in MAT 1594 of 2018 & all other matters.

Mr. Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya Mr. Dibyendu Chatterjee Ms. Piyali Paul Ms. Jhuma Chakraborty Mr. Rahul Deb Goenka Mr. Pritam Mazumder .... for the Respondent in MAT 1594 of 2018 & Writ Petitioner in WPA 10005 of 2021, WPA 10909 of 2018, WPA 14736 of 2021, WPA 16598 of 2019 WPA 17749 of 2018, WPA 18370 of 2019, WPA 1991 of 2021, WP 20132 of 2018, WPA 20219 of 2019, WPA 21717 of 2019, WPA 21751 of 2019, WPA 22274 of 2018, WPA 22507 of 2018, WPA 22848 of 2018, WPA 23013 of 2018, WPA 23016 of

2018, WPA 24496 of 2018, WPA 24499 of 2018, WPA 24520 of 2018, WPA 24522 of 2018, WPA 24523 of 2018, WPA 24556 of 2018, WPA 25180 of 2018, WPA 25502 of 2018 and WPA 2628 of 2021, WPA 2021/2019 WPA 204/2021, WPA 21751/2019, WPA 8028/2022.

Mr. Kamalesh Bhattacharyya Mr. Aninda Bhattacharya .....for the petitioner in WPA 5663 of 2021, WPA 2800 of 2019 & WPA 26146 of 2018.

Mr. Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya Mr. Sudipta Dasgupta Mr. Bikram Banerjee Mr. Arka Nandi Ms. Dipa Acharya Mr. Sutirtha Nayek Ms. Shalini Ghosh ... for the Respondent in MAT 1594/2018 & MAT 953/2021 & Writ Petitioner in WPA 16436 of 2018, WPA 16438 of 2018, WPA 16440 of 2018, WPA 16448 of 2018 and WPA 16449 of 2018.

Mr. Ali Ahsan Alamgir Ms. Rabia Khatoon Ms. Soma Mal ..... for the Intervenor in MAT 999 of 2021 and MAT 1594 of 2018 & applicants in CAN 42/2022, CAN 43/2022, CAN 61/2022, CAN 62/2022 and WPA 7809 of 2019 of CAN 120/2022, CAN 146/2022, CAN 147/2022, CAN 149/2022, CAN 155/2022, CAN 157/2022, CAN 158/2022, CAN 162/2022, CAN 167/2022, CAN 171/2022, CAN 177/2022, CAN 178/2022, CAN 180/2022, CAN 181/2022, CAN 196 of 2022 & CAN 199 of 2022.

Mr. Ali Ahsan Alamgir Ms. Rabia Khatoon Ms. Soma Mal ..... for the Appellant in MAT 999/2021 & Writ Petitioner in WPA10304/23019,WPA10306/2019, WPA10308/2019,WPA10540/2019, WPA10541/2019,WPA10543/2019, WPA10800/2019,WPA10803/2019, WPA11001/2019,WPA11002/2019,WPA

11003/2019,WPA1125/2021, WPA11701/2019,WPA11702/2019,WPA 12021/2019,WPA13016/2019,WPA 16242/2019,WPA16244/2019,WPA 164/2022,WPA17003/2019,WPA 17024/2018,WPA17025/2018,WPA 1704/2012,WPA1729/2022, WPA 1732/2022, WPA17406/2019,WPA17408/2019,WPA 17009/2018,WPA17018 of 2018, WPA 17944/2019, WPA 18865/2018, WPA 18880/2021, WPA 19052/2019, WPA 19087/2019, WPA 19432/2019, WPA 19607/2018, WPA 19608/2018, WPA 20227/2019, WPA 20314/2018, WPA 20317/2018, WPA 20332/2019, 20341/2019, WPA 204/2022, WPA 20642/2021, WPA 2097/2022, WPA 21191/2018, WPA 219/2021, WPA 2245/2021, WPA 314/2019, WPA 5584/2022, WPA 8290/2019, WPA 8613/2019, WPA 8614/2019, WPA 8889/2021, WPA 9947/2019, WPA 22732/2018 & WPA 26146 of 2018.

Mr. Firdous Samim Ms. Gopa Biswas Ms. Mousumi Hazra .... for the Writ Petitioner in WPA 10954 of 2021, WPA 10958 of 2021, WPA 11433 of 2020, WPA1971 of 2021, WPA 20246 of 2018, WPA 20249 of 2018, WPA 20251 of 2018, WPA 20253 of 2018, WPA20255 of 2018, WPA 20257 of 2018, WPA 20258 of 2018, WPA 20260 of 2018, WPA 20262 of 2018, WPA 20263 of 2018, WPA20264 of 2018, WPA 20265 of 2018, WPA 20484 of 2018, WPA 20495 of 2018, WPA 21398 of 2018, WPA 21407 of 2018, WPA 21411 of 2018, WPA 21766 of2018, WPA 229 of 2021, WPA 22962 of 2018, WPA 22998 of 2018, WPA 23609 of 2019, WPA 26065 of 2018, WPA 26067 of 2018 WPA 26069 of 2018, WPA 26071 of 2018, WPA 26076 of 2018, WPA 26078 of 2018, WPA 26084 of 2018, WPA 26317 of 2018, WPA 26320 of 2018, WPA 2811 of 2019, WPA 348 of 2022, WPA 349 of 2022, WPA 350 of 2022, WPA 351 of 2022, WPA 4083 of 2021, WPA 7988 of 2021 and WPA 824 of 2021.

Mr. Firdous Samim Ms. Gopa Biswas Ms. Moushumi Hazra

.......for the applicants in CAN 7 of 2022 and CAN 8 of 2022, CAN 94 of 2022, CAN 102 of 2022, CAN 108 of 2022, CAN 118 of 2022, CAN 132 of 2022, CAN 177 of 2022, CAN 187 of 2022.

Mr. Amit Kumar Dutta ...for the petitioner in WPA 19672/2019.

Mr. Gautam Banerjee Mr. Sandip Kumar Mondal Ms. Priya Dey Mr. Sumit Routh Ms. Chumki Das Bairagya Ms. Riya Das ....for the petitioner in WPA 202/2022 & applicant in CAN 66/2022, CAN 13 of 2022, CAN 14 of 2022, CAN 15 of 2022, CAN 16 of 2022, CAN 17 of 2022, CAN 19 of 2022, CAN 23 of 2022, CAN 36 of 2022, CAN 37 of 2022, CAN 38 of 2022, CAN 39 of 2022, CAN 44 of 2022, CAN 46 of 2022, CAN 48 of 2022, CAN 50 of 2022, CAN 51 of 202, CAN 55 of 2022, CAN 58 of 2022, CAN 60 of 2022, CAN 64 of 2022, CAN 70 of 2022, CAN 73 of 2022, CAN 74 of 2022, CAN 75 of 2022.

Mr. Sudipta Dasgupta .... for the Appellant in MAT 1594 of 2018 & Writ Petitioner in WPA 16436 of 2018, WPA 16438 of 2018, WPA 16440 of 2018, WPA 16448 of 2018, WPA 16449 of 2018.

Mr. Goutam Dey Mr. Dipendu Sarkar Mr. Kaushal Kumar Ms. Ankita Ghosh ...... for the petitioner in WPA 1099/2021, WPA 668/2021, WPA 738/2021, WPA816/2021.

Mr. Atarup Banerjee Mr. Abu Sohel Ms. Poulami Roy .... for the petitioner in WPA 7809 of 2019.

Mr. Avirup Chatterjee ..... for the petitioner in WPA18329/2021,WPA 2469/2021, WPA 4414/2021, WPA 4920/2022, WPA 5482/2021,WPA 9188/2021,

WPA 1053/2022, WPA 6158/2022.

Mr. Gazi Faruque Hossain Ms. Priyanka Mondal ....for the petitioner in WPA 22701 of 2019, WPA 4954 of 2020, WPA 4955 of 2020, WPA 6291 of 2021.

Mr. Anindya Bose Mr. Diptendu Mondal Mr. Nikhil Kr. Gupta Mr. Mridul Biswas ......for the petitioners in WPA 21859/2018, WPA 23353/2018 WPA 24917/2018, WPA 24919/2018 WPA 17619/2018, WPA 4451/2019 WPA 590/2019, WPA 1396/2021, WPA 23353/2018, WPA 24234/2018.

Mr. Avijit Chakraborty .... for the petitoner in WPA 14722 of 2021, WPA 14728 of 2021 and WPA 14736 of 2021.

Mr. Sukanta Chakraborty Mr. Juber Ahamed .... In WPA 2460 of 2018.

Mr. S.P. Lahiri Mr. R. Naskar .... for the petitioner in WPA 1316 of 2022, WPA 2719 of 2021 and WPA 5550 of 2021.

Ms. Rama Haldar ..... for the petitioner in WPA 21725/2018, WPA 2802/2021, WPA 689/2022, WPA 21649/2018, WPA 21650/2018,.

Mr. Biswarup Biswas Mr. Samik Dey Mr. Subhadeep Adhikari .... for the applicant/petitioner in CAN 56/2022 & 57/2022 of MAT 1594 of 2018.

Mr. Ritam Chowdhury ... For the addition of party in CAN 63 of 2022, CAN 69 of 2022.

Mr. Shamit Sanyal

Ms. Priyakshi Banerjee Mr. Sabyasachi Roy ..... For the petitioner in WPA 21766 of 2018.

Mr. Rajarshi Basu Mr. S.T. Mina ..... for the State in WPA 16448 of 2018.

Mr. Rajaram Banerjee ..... For the State in WPA 5663 of 2021, WPA19432 of 2019.

Mr. Pratick Sardar ....... For the Resp. in WPA 16448 of 2018.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Ranjan Saha ..... for the State in WPA 10954 of 2018, WPA 10958 of 2018.

Mr. Rabi Sankar Chattopahyay Mr. Sayan Chattopadhyay Mr. Ivan Sarkar Mr. R. Ali Molla .... For the applicant in CAN 37 of 2022 & CAN 49 of 2022.

Mr. Anshuman Chakraborty Mr. Prasanta Bishal ..... for the applicant CAN 150/2022 of WPA 7809/2019.

Mr. Prabir Kr. Chowdhuri .... For the applicant CAN 152/2022, CAN 159/2022 of WPA 7809/2019.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Arindam Chattopadhyay ..... for the State in WPA 16536 of 2021.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Sagnik Chatterjee ..... for the State in WPA 20988 of 2019.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Suman Dey .... for the State in WPA 7809 of 2019 & for DPSC in WPA 8290 of 2019

Mr. Amal Kumar Sen, Ld. AGP Mr. Sajal Pandit ..... for the State in MAT 953 of 2021 Mr. Pinaki Dhole Mr. Avishek Prasad ... for the State in WPA 14728 of 2021.

Mr. Arindam Chattopadhyay ..... for the DPSC in MAT 1594 of 2018 & for State in WPA 16536 of 2021.

Mr. Arindam Chattopadhyay Ms. Lipika Chatterjee Mr. Bhaksar Prasad Vaisya ..... for the State in WPA 10909 of 2018, WPA 20255 of 2018, WPA 21766 of 2018, WPA 23609 of 2019 and WPA 2460 of 2018, WPA 16536/2021.

Mr. Susanta Pal Mr. Prabir Kumar Roy .... For the State in WPA 20257 of 2018, WPA 20314/2018.

Mr. Susovan Sengupta Mr. Manas Kumar Sadhu .... for the State in WPA 25375 of 2018.

Mr. Arindam Chattopadhyay Ms. Lipika Chatterjee .... for the DPSC, Nadia/State in MAT 1594 of 2018, WPA 12021/2019, WPA 10306/2019, WPA 10541/2019, WPA 10909/2018, WPA 10950/2019, WPA 11001/2019, WPA 1125 /2021, WPA 17024/2018, WPA17944/2019, WPA 19052/2019, WPA19607/2018, WPA 8614/2019, WPA 19733/2018, WPA 20255/2018, WPA 20257/2018, WPA 21760/2018, WPA 2460/2018, WPA 314/2019, WPA 19672/2019, WPA 3121 of 2021, WPA 23609/2018, WPA 2460/2018, WPA 314/2019, WPA 19672/2019, WPA 3121/2021, WPA 12021/2019, WPA 10956/2019,WPA17014/2018,WPA 17944/2019, WPA19052/2019, WPA 19607/2018, WPA 8614/2019.

Mr. Supriya Chattopadhyay

Ms. Iti Dutta .... for the DPSC, Dakshin Dinajpur in WPA 17749 of 2018 and State in WPA 1732/2022, WPA 7988/2021.

Mr. Suman Dey ..... for the State in WPA 1053 of 2022, WPA 2802 of 2021 & WPA 8290 of 2019.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Nilay Baran Mondal ..... for the DPSC in WPA 21649 of 2018, WPA 21650/2018.

Mr. Kamal Mishra .... For the DPSC, Purba Medinipur in WPA 7809/2019.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Suman Dey Mr. Sagnik Chatterjee Mr. Pinaki Bhattacharyya Mr. Nilay Baran Mondal .... For the DPSC in WPA 20132 of 2018.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Raja Saha Mr. Suman Dey ..... for the State in WPA 10954/2018, WPA 10958/2018 WPA 202/2022.

Mr. Raja Saha Mr. Binekananda Tripathy ...... for the State in WPA 8028 of 2022.

Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Vaisya Mr. Suman Dey ..... for the State in WPA 7809/2019 & WPA 202 of 2022.

Mr. Asit Baran Ghosh Mr. Somesh Ghosh .... for the Added Resp. in WPA 7809 of 2019.

Mr. Rudra Prasad Sinha Ms. Aparupa Bhattacharyya ... for the Resp. in MAT 1594/2018 of CAN 65/2022.

Mr. Santanu Maji Mr. Sayan Chattopadhyay Mr. Subhayu Das ...

..... for the applicant in CAN 37 of 2022 in MAT 1594 of 2018 and CAN 168 of 2022 & CAN 183 of 2022 in WPA 7809 of 2019.

Mr. Sandipan Das Ms. Indrani Roy .... for the applicant in CAN 39 of 2022, CAN 52 of 2022 & CAN 72 of 2022 of MAT 1594 of 2018.

Mr. Sauvik Nandy .... For the NCTE in all matters.

Mr. Gopal Das ... for the Writ Petitioner in WPA 2397 of 2021, WPA 2400 of 2021, WPA 2733 of 2021, WPA 3969 of 2022 & WPA 3972 of 2022 and for applicant in CAN 80 of 2020 and CAN 82 of 2021 of WPA 7809 of 2019 and CAN 7990 of 2019 and CAN 8003 of 2019 of MAT 1594 of 2018 and WPA 7909 of 2019.

Ms. Tamali Dutta Roy Mr. Sukanta Chakraborty Mr. Zubin Ahamed ......for the petitioner/respondent in WPA 2460/2018.

Mr. Samim Ahammed Ms. Ambiya Khatun .... for the applicant in CAN 11 of 2022 of MAT 1594 of 2018.

Mr. K.D. Poddar Mr. Amit Kr. Dutta .... for the applicant in CAN 1 of 2022 of WPA 19672 of 2019.

Mr. Suman Dey Mr. Subhadeep Adhikari ... for the applicant in CAN 56 of 0222, CAN 57 of 2022. In MAT 1594/2018.

Mr. Sudipta Panda Ms. Munmun Tewari .... for the State in WPA 22962 of 2021, WPA 10803 of 2019, WPA 14736 of 2021.

Ms. Sujata Mukherjee ... for the petitioner in WPA 3121/2021.

Mr. Swapan Kr. Dutta, Ld. AGP.

Mr. Pradyut Kr. Das Mr. Rajat Dutta ....... for the State in WPA 2097/2022, WPA 5584/2022.

Mr. Sajal Kumar Pandit ..... for the State in WPA 20990/2019, WPA 10800/2019.

Mr. Rabindra Nath Pal ...... for the State in WPA 8290 of 2019.

Mr. Tapas Kumar Mondal .... For the State in WPA 24556/2018.

Mr. Arindam Chattopadhyay ... For the DPSC, Nadia in MAT 1594/2018.

Mr. Tulshi Das Roy ..... for the State in WPA 10308/2019, WPA 16598/2019, WPA 17025/2018, WPA 17406/2019, WPA 19733/2018 & WPA 20251/2018.

Mr. Goutam Banerjee Ms. Priya Dey ... for the applicants in all matters.

Ms. Reshmi Ghosh Mr. Golam Mahiuddin Mr. Raja Mandal ..... for the applicants of CAN 193 of 2022 & CAN 194 of 2022 in WPA 7809 of 2019.

Ms. Sonam Ray ..... for the applicant of CAN 53 of 2022 in MAT 1594 of 2018.

Mr. Debasis Roy Sk. Md. Masud ... For the State in WPA 6291 of 2021.

Party/parties is/are represented in the order of their name/names as printed above in the cause title. Both Mr. Lakhi Kumar Gupta, Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellants/West Bengal Board of Primary Education (for short, the Board) and Mr. Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharyya, Learned Counsel appearing for the Respondents/The Writ Petitioners, complete their submissions. The submissions in both the parent appeals, being MAT 1594 of 2018 and MAT 953 of 2021, stand accordingly concluded.

Parties representing the connected writ petitioners and the applicants adopt the respective submissions of the appellants/the Board and the Respondents/the Writ Petitioners.

Parties agree to file their Notes of Arguments within 20th of January, 2023.

Hearing stands accordingly concluded.

Judgement stands reserved.

All parties to act in terms of the copy of the order downloaded from the official website of this Court. (Supratim Bhattacharya, J.) (Subrata Talukdar, J.)