Farman Ali Ibrahim Bhombal v. Sitaram Chotelal Adiwadi And ORS.

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION FIRST APPEAL NO. 194/2021 RAGHU BHAGU SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FIRST APPEAL NO. 733/2024 INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 18446/2022 IN FIRST APPEAL NO. 733/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE BABAN BHAIRU SANE AND ORS FA/715/2024 IA/18448/2022 IN FA/715/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY, M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE NARAYAN RAGHU SANE(DECEASED)THR.LRS.

1.1)ANUSAYA NARAYAN SANE(DECEASED) THR.LRS.2,3 AND 4 AND ORS.

FA/722/2024 IA/18452/2022 IN FA/722/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc BABAN DHONDIBA SANE ANR ORS.

FA/723/2024 IA/18450/2022 IN FA/723/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE RAGHU BHAGU SANE & ORS.

FA/719/2024 IA/18459/2022 IN FA/719/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE SAKHARAM TUKARAM SANE (DECD.) THR. LRS. 1.1.) RAGHU S. SANE & ORS.

FA/727/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE RAGHU BHAGU SANE & ORS.

FA/730/2024 IA/18454/2022 IN FA/730/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C.,

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE DINKAR KRISHNA GODEKAR & ORS.

FA/732/2024 IA/18439/2022 IN FA/732/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE DHONDIBA GANPAT SANE (DECD.) THR.

LRS. 1.1 G.D.SANE & ORS.

FA/729/2024 IA/18437/2022 IN FA/729/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE RAGHU BHAGU SANE & ORS.

FA/724/2024 IA/18461/2022 IN FA/724/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE DHONDIBA DAGDU SANE (DECD.) THR.

HIS LRS. 1.1 BABAN DHONDIBA SANE ..RESPONDENT FA/718/2024

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc IA/18435/2022 IN FA/718/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE RAKHMAJI YESHU CHIKANE & ORS.

FA/725/2024 IA/18486/2022 IN FA/725/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE DHONDIBA YASHWANT PARTE & ORS.

FA/717/2024 IA/18474/2022 IN FA/717/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE BABAN BHAIRU SANE & ORS.

FA/728/2024 IA/18478/2022 IN FA/728/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc MAHADU BAPU SHEDGE (DECD.) THR HIS LRS.1.1 SMT. KALABAI MAHADU @ MAHADEO SHEDGE & ORS.

FA/716/2024 IA/18484/2022 IN FA/716/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE DHONDIBA YASHWANT PARTHY & ORS.

FA/720/2024 IA/18481/2022 IN FA/720/2022 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE LAXMAN BABURAO PILANE (DECD.)THR.

LRS. 1.1) PRADEEP LAXMAN PILANE & ORS.

FA/721/2024 IA/18469/2022 IN FA/721/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE SAKHARAM TUKARAM SANE (DECD.) THR LRS 1.1 RAGHU SAKAHARAM SANE & ORS.

FA/714/2024

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc IA/18491/2022 IN FA/714/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE SUDHIR SHANKAR ALIAS DINKAR SANE & ORS. ..RESPONDENTS FA/731/2024 IA/18493/2022 IN FA/731/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE RAKHAKAJIYESHU CHIKANE & ORS.

FA/726/2024 IA/18488/2022 IN FA/726/2024 THE ACQUIRING BODY,M.K.V.D.C., NIRA DEOGHAR IRRIGATION PROJECT THR.S.D.O./EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PUNE BAPU KRISHNA MAHASAVADE & ORS.

FA/264/2025 FARMAN ALI IBRAHIM BHOMBAL SITARAM CHOTELAL ADIWADI & ORS.

FA/90/2023 DAGDU JANU SANE (DECD.) THR. LRS.

1.1 SHAKUNTALA DAGDU SANE & ORS.

VS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc PUNE & ORS.

FA/172/2021 LAXMAN BABURAO PILANE (DEC.) THR. LRS. ANUSAYA LAXMAN PILANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS FA/309/2022 BAPU KRISHNA MAHASAVADE THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/685/2022 RAKHAMAJI YESHU CHIKANE AND ANR.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE ..RESPONDENT FA/850/2022 RAKHAMAJI YESHU CHIKANE AND ANR.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE ..RESPONDENT FA/173/2021 DHONDIBA GANPAT SANE (DECEASED) THR. HIS LRS. 1A) GANESH DHONDIBA SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE ..RESPONDENT FA/170/2021 NARAYAN RAGHU SANE (DECESED) THR. HIS LRS. 1A) ANUSAYA NARAYAN

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc SANE (DECEASED) THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE ..RESPONDENT FA/192/2021 BABAN BHAIRU SANE AND ORS VS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE ..RESPONDENT FA/177/2021 DHONDIBA SAKAHARAM SANE (DECEASED) THR. HIS LRS.1A RAGHUJI DHONDIBA SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE ..RESPONDENT FA/200/2021 DINKAR KRISHNA GADEKAR THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/331/2022 BABAN BHAIRU SANE THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/660/2022 RAGHU BHAGU SANE THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/176/2021 DHONDIBA YASHWANT PARTHE & ORS.

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/310/2022 DHONDIBA YESHWANT PARTHE VS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/424/2022 DINKAR KRISHNA GODEKAR THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS FA/627/2022 SHIVRAM SAKHARAM PARTE AND ORS.

VS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

..RESPONDENTS.

FA/403/2022 SHIVRAM SAKHARAM PARTHE THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/175/2021 RAGHU BHAGU SANE THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS FA/312/2022 MAHADU BAPU SHEDGE (DECEASED) THR. L.R.S. KALABAI MAHADU @ MAHADEO SHEDGE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc FA/650/2022 SUDHIR SHANKAR @ DINKAR SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/651/2022 SAKHARAM TUKARMA SANE (DECEASED) THR. LRS. 1A) RAGHU SAKARAM SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.

17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/408/2022 BABAN DHONDIBA SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FA/593/2021 DHONDIBA DAGDU SANE (DECEASED) THR. HIS LRS. 1A) BABAN DHONDIBA SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS FA/681/2022 SAKHARAM TUKARMA SANE (DECEASED) THR. LRS. 1A) RAGHU SAKARAM SANE AND ORS.

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER NO.17 PUNE AND ORS.

FIRST APPEAL NO. 154/2022 CHOLAMANDALAML INSURANCE CO. LTD.

THR. ITS MANAGER

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc CHARU ASHOK KHANDAL AND ORS.

..RESPONDENT FIRST APPEAL NO. 140/2022 THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICE AND ANR.

SHRI. LAXMAN SAKHARAM MINMINE & ORS.

FIRST APPEAL NO. 169/2022 RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, MUMBAI CHHAYA RAMESH SONAWANE AND ANR.

FIRST APPEAL NO. 120/2022 CHOLAMANDALAM M.S. GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. THR ITS MANAGER HEMANT B. GAOKAR SHRI. PUNJARAM BHILA KHAIRNAR & ORS.

FIRST APPEAL NO. 621/2022 VALJIBHAI RANSHIBHAI VARCHAND & ORS.

THE MUNICIPAL CORPORATION OF GR.

MUMBAI THROUGH THE GENERAL MANAGER ..RESPONDENT ------------ Adv. Amrita Kharkar a/w. Adv. Sayalee Bhosale i/b. Adv. P. H. Potnis for the appellants in FA/194/2021 a/w. other matters. Adv. Yash S. a/w. Adv. Ramesh Dubepatil, Adv. Vivek Yadav i/b. Jay & Co. for appellants in FA/729/2024, FA/723/2024, FA/733/2024, FA/715/2024, FA/722/2024, FA/727/2024, FA/730/2024. Adv. Shagufa Patel through VC for respondents. Mr. A. R. Patil, Addl. G.P. for State.

None for the appellants in FA/154/2022, FA/140/2022, FA/169/2022, FA/120/2022 and FA/621/2022.

Adv. Karishma Jhaveri for the respondent (BEST) in FA/621/2022. ------------

Diksha Rane 26.1 FA 154 2022 & ORS..doc CORAM :

RAJESH S. PATIL, J.

DATE :

10 APRIL 2026.

P.C. :

FA/154/2022, FA/140/2022, FA/169/2022, FA/120/2022 and FA/621/2022:- 1) As the present first appeals are not connected with this group, the same be de-tagged from this group.

FIRST APPEAL NO. 154/2022 a/w. CONNECTED MATTERS:- 2) By consent, let this group of matters be placed on 4/5/2026, at 1.00 p.m.

3) Matter to come up under the caption "For Final Hearing". (Rajesh S. Patil, J.) Signed by: Diksha Rane Designation: PS To Honourable Judge Date: 15/04/2026 18:07:55