Ramesh J. Kamble v. Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai And ORS.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION FIRST APPEAL NO.1843 OF 2024 Shilpi Minz T Ltd., Mumbai And Ors. ... Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr. ... Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 589 OF 2025 Ms. Vibhuti Chavan...............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd & Anr.
....Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1788 OF 2024 Mr. Pawankumar M. Dayma.................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1802 OF 2024 Narendra Kashinath Meher.................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1801 OF 2024 Krishna Hiraji Patil.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd.and Ors. . ...Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1822 OF 2024 Eknath Kisan Malekar...........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr ....Respondents..
1 of
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1817 OF 2024 Charulata Parag Chitnis.......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Ors.
....Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1818 OF 2024 Gajanan Siddheshwar Shinde..............................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr,.................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1819 OF 2024 Mr. Ashok W. Rane................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr, Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1919 OF 2024 Shazia Shaikh.........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1926 OF 2024 Arvind Hari Naik....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................
Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1931 OF 2024 Nilesh Pandurang Lanjekar..................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1929 OF 2024 Shaima Prasad.......................................................................................
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1934 OF 2024 Ravi Prakash Bhargava.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1932 OF 2024 Santosh Narayan Suryawanshi............................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Anr................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1938 OF 2024 Khalid Sabri............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Anr................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1933 OF 2024 Mrs. Chinar Amitabh Panchbhai..........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd.
And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1925 OF 2024 Jitendra Sahadev Parab.......................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1939 OF 2024 Prashant Kamalakar Parulekar............................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1947 OF 2024 Swapnil Ravindra Gawde......................................................................
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1940 OF 2024 Raghunath Ganpat Khot......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1936 OF 2024 Rashmi Minz...........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1949 OF 2024 Shobha Ramesh Sanap.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1943 OF 2024 Jitendra Kumar Sarangi........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1941 OF 2024 Pankaj Chauhan.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr.....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1945 OF 2024 Bechanram Yadav..................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1965 OF 2024 Nilesh R. Sakhare...................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Ors..................................Respondent 4 of
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1958 OF 2024 Ashok Waman Milkhe...........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1957 OF 2024 Vishal Waman Dawne...........................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1963 OF 2024 Deepak Sequeira...................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1962 OF 2024 Neena Nachankar..................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO.
1960 OF 2024 Chau Mikalen Enling.............................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1964 OF 2024 Manoranjan Baishakha.........................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1969 OF 2024 Narsinha Patil.........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1959 OF 2024 Vishnu Manik Gawali.............................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1970 OF 2024 Milind N. Moghe....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1961 OF 2024 Mr. Shashikant Kundlik Salunke..........................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1967 OF 2024 Amit Ashok Tikam.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1977 OF 2024 Ashish Mishra.........................................................................................
Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Ors..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1972 OF 2024 Mr. Rajesh Z. Tatkare............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1975 OF 2024 Sujay Basu...............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1986 OF 2024 Arvind Umaji Nagvekar........................................................................
Mumbai International Airport , Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1984 OF 2024 Suresh Vishwanath Yadav....................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 36 OF 2025 Mahadev Desai......................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 37 OF 2025 C. Iqbal....................................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Anr... .Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 49 OF 2025 Uttam Gopal Patra................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 51 OF 2025 Vivek Karnad..........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 39 OF 2025 Sangita Singh.........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 56 OF 2025 Sandeep A. Gajbhiye.............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Ors..................................Respondent 7 of
FIRST APPEAL NO. 50 OF 2025 Nitin Shivaji Satam................................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 48 OF 2025 Ganesh Madhukar Savekar..................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 38 OF 2025 Sunil Dagadu Sonawane.......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 44 OF 2025 S. Sivakumar...........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 41 OF 2025 Gangishetti Veeresham........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Ors.
...Respondent.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 47 OF 2025 S.D. Chaube............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr..
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 73 OF 2025 Suryakant D. Hegiste............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent 8 of
FIRST APPEAL NO. 67 OF 2025 R.S. Chavan.............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 66 OF 2025 Ashok L. Bhilare.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 75 OF 2025 Sanjay Gopal Rane.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 70 OF 2025 Sumedh Sadashiv Waghmare..............................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr. ....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 68 OF 2025 Mr. Ashish A. Gaikwad..........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 76 OF 2025 Nitin Laxman Nikam.............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 82 OF 2025 Reshma S. Thakkar................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. 9 of
FIRST APPEAL NO. 80 OF 2025 Vilas Shankar Bhosle............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 83 OF 2025 Dharmendra B. Shirkar.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 78 OF 2025 Mr. Swarup Chaudhuri..........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 77 OF 2025 Ms. Madhumita Mondal.......................................................................Appellant Mumbai Internation Airport Ltd Mumbai And.............................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 84 OF 2025 Jitendra R. Salve....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., And Anr.
...Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 79 OF 2025 R. N. Pagare............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 81 OF 2025 Prakash P. Gusai.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 122 OF 2025 Deepti Shrestha.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 127 OF 2025 Meenakshi S. Bais..................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 132 OF 2025 Anil Sayaji Shikhare...............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 169 OF 2025 Darshana Vinayak Bangre....................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr.. ..Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 575 OF 2025 Sandeep Ganpat Drave........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Pvt Ltd. And and Anr. Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 602 OF 2025 Vikas Nagvekar......................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr.. ..Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 576 OF 2025 Mr. Sameer Chhabu Tadvi....................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd Mumbai and Anr... .Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 560 OF 2025
Mr. S. Hansda..........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 556 OF 2025 Ravindra Vasant Shinde.......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 585 OF 2025 Mr. Satyawan N. Babar.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 571 OF 2025 Sunil D. Kumbhar...................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr.................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 601 OF 2025 Mr.
Pramod Kumar Sharma..................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 586 OF 2025 Mr. Mohammed Hashim Ansari...........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 577 OF 2025 Sandip Meshram....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 580 OF 2025 Stephen John Vaz.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 579 OF 2025 Mr. Yogesh V. Bhat................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 553 OF 2025 Mr. Kamalakar Shripati Kamble..........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 582 OF 2025 Ramesh M. Adep....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 552 OF 2025 Mr. Ramesh Vishnu Narayankar..........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr ....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 561 OF 2025 Tushar Kanti Sarkar...............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 588 OF 2025 Mr. Milind S. Lokhande.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 566 OF 2025 T. R. Satish...............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr ....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO. 32446 OF 2024 Ms. Bhavisha Odedra............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO. 26209 OF 2024 Nandapu Jagadeswar Rao...................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 42 OF 2025 Vithoba N. Tervankar............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 71 OF 2025 Prashant Kisan Gaigole Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Ors.
....Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 69 OF 2025 Ganesh Shivaji Ingavale........................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 1944 OF 2024 Mohammad Rafi C.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Ors.
....Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1800 OF 2024 Dilip Janardan Gamare.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 55 OF 2025 Maxie E Dias...........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 567 OF 2025 Mr. Ganesh Kumar Ganga Singh..........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1924 OF 2024 Dinesh Yashwant Gajakosh..................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1987 OF 2024 Mahesh Hamne......................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 587 OF 2025 Mr. K.
J. Lassar.......................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 54 OF 2025 Shailesh Madhukar Kolambkar...........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 590 OF 2025 Mr. Sanjay Shantaram Tendulkar........................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO.
Mr. Prashant B. Mahadik......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 555 OF 2025 Mr. Kailash Vinayak Pavitrekar............................................................Appellant Mumbai International Aiport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr. ..................... Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 563 OF 2025 Mr. Manoj Vitthal Solanki.....................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1803 OF 2024 Ganesh Pandurang Khedekar..............................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1804 OF 2024 Shankar Yogendra Shahu.....................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. ....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1883 OF 2024 Sandesh V. Shirodkar............................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 175 OF 2025 Mohan R. Dane......................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1942 OF 2024
Dinesh Manohar Pange........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 52 OF 2025 Rajendra Kumar Pandey.......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Ors..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 72 OF 2025 Prem Singh.............................................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 74 OF 2025 Ramesh J. Kamble.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Ors. Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 65 OF 2025 Mr. M. Paramasivan Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 565 OF 2025 Neil Gaikwad..........................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Mumbai and Ors. Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 572 OF 2025 Mr. Sanjay Bhise.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr ....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1990 OF 2024 Anil Kumar Verma.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1966 OF 2024 R.B. Mali..................................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1978 OF 2024 Alkeshkumar Ramjibhai Parmar..........................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO. 32442 OF 2024 Mr. Rahul Deore.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd Mumbai and Anr....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 581 OF 2025 Vijay Mates Rosario..............................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 600 OF 2025 Ajay Gupta..............................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr.. ..Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 574 OF 2025 Ms. Shramika B. Ubale..........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr..................................Respondent
FIRST APPEAL NO. 578 OF 2025 Mr. Sunil Kumar.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. Mumbai and Anr ....Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 559 OF 2025 Ms. Suchitra Mangrati.........................................................................Appellant Mumbai Internatinal Airport Ltd Mum & Anr....Respondents. FIRST APPEAL NO. 564 OF 2025 Mr. Sachin Shivalkar..............................................................................Appellant Mumbai Internatinal Airport Ltd Mum & Anr..
..Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1946 OF 2024 Sangdra Rodrigues................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. And Or.s. .Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 1921 OF 2024 Ninad B. Vaity........................................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 583 OF 2025 Ms. Parul Kailas Meshram Appellant Mumbai Internatinal Airport Ltd Mum & Anr.
...Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1806 OF 2024 Mr. Deepak S. Pawaskar.......................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr,.................................Respondent
FIRST APPEAL NO. 130 OF 2025 Sanjeevika Sarmal.................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1805 OF 2024 Vilas Kaluram Jadhav...........................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr,.................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 603 OF 2025 Shobha J. Pujari.....................................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd., Mumbai and Anr....Respondents.. FIRST APPEAL NO. 570 OF 2025 Ms. Vineeta Shakya...............................................................................Appellant FIRST APPEAL NO. 558 OF 2025 Ms. Poonam Parihar Borana................................................................Appellant Mumbai Internatinal Airport Ltd Mum Anr.
..Respondents..
FIRST APPEAL NO. 562 OF 2025 Mr. Sayyed Shahid Akhtar....................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airport Ltd. And Anr.................................Respondent FIRST APPEAL NO. 568 OF 2025 Joshua Barnabas Devi..........................................................................Appellant Mumbai Internatinal Airport Ltd Mum & Anr . ..Respondents.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 53 OF 2025 Akshay Lalitkumar Chonkar.................................................................Appellant Mumbai International Airports Ltd. And Ors.. Respondents. ------ Mr. Mihir Desai, Senior Advocate along with Mr. Ashok Shetty, Rita K. Joshi, Mishra and Mr. Rahul Shetty for the Appellants (Except FA No. 169/2025) Amrendra Sinha, Priyanka Suresh Kale for the Appellant in FA 169/2025. Mr. Vikram Nankani, Senior Advocate along with Mr. Chirag Kamdar, Ms. Samruddhi Mali and Mr. Suhas K. for the Respondent No. 1. Shilpa Kapil, Chidanand Kapil, Chandru Bavishi and Priti Karbhari for the Respondent No. 2.
------ Coram : Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J.
Date : May 2, 2025.
P. C. :
1.
Arguments are concluded. Written submissions are tendered. The same are taken on record. Reserved for Judgment. [Sharmila U. Deshmukh, J.] Signed by: Sachin R. Patil Designation: PS To Honourable Judge Date: 06/05/2025 21:29:11