Shankar Nillapa Dhub And ANR v. The State Of Maharashtra Thr The Collector Rehabilitation And ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIRCUIT BENCH AT KOLHAPUR CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 6974 OF 2025 Shankar Nillapa Dhub And Anr ... Petitioners Digitally signed by UDAY SHIVAJI JAGTAP Date:
2026.03.24 11:06:11 +0530 UDAY SHIVAJI JAGTAP
Versus
The State Of Maharashtra Thr The Collector Rehabilitation and Ors.
... Respondents ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 6837 OF 2025 Dastgir Rajesh Chadedar And Anr ... Petitioners
Versus
The State Of Maharashtra Thr The Collector Rehabilitation and Ors.
... Respondents ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 6963 OF 2025 Parshu Topanna Jinrale, Deceased Thr Lrs ... Petitioners
Versus
The State Of Maharashtra Thr. The Collector Rehabilitation and Ors.
... Respondents .............
Mr. Vikrant Anand Desai for the Petitioners.
Mr. Siddheshwar B. Kalel, AGP for Respondent - State in WP 6974/2025. Mr. V.M. Mali, AGP for Respondent - State in WP 6837/2025. Mr. A.A. Naik, AGP for Respondent - State in WP 6963/2025. .............
CORAM : MADHAV J. JAMDAR & PRAVIN S. PATIL, JJ.
1 of
DATE : 23rd MARCH, 2026.
P. C. :
1.
Heard Mr. Desai, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners and Mr. Kalel, Mr. Mali and Mr. Naik, learned AGPs for the respondent - State in respective petitions.
2.
As the issues involved in all these Writ Petitions are identical, these petitions are taken up for hearing together.
3.
Mr. Desai, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, has confined his relief to the alternate prayer of directing the authorities to decide the petitioners' representation afresh. It is his submission that certain points, which are mentioned in the representation are not taken into consideration. To substantiate the said contention, he points out the contentions raised on page 250 and 251 in the representation dated 4th December 2022, annexed to Writ Petition No. 6974 of 2025. The relevant portion reads as under :- "
मौजेतेरणीयेथील्याजमीनीवरतीआमचीउपिजिवकावाानुवा चालायची्या सुिपकजमीनीआं्हीिवनातराररयायीजमीनमागणीनकरता१००% मोबदला रकमि*वकाूनताबािदलेलाआहे.
िनवाडयारमाणेिमळाले्यारकमेम्ये रक्पर*तअ्यि3काणीजमीनखरेदीघेवून*वतःचेपुनवसनकूनघेवूशकत नाही्हणून्यालासहकाय ्हावेहाचउदेश3ेवून१९७६पूव> पासूनआपलेकडील शासनिनणयारमाणेजेरक्पर*त१००% रकमउचलकरतात्यांनापुनवसन अनुदानदेयआहे.
व्यारमाणेसंपूण महाराटराजाम्येपुनवसनअनुदानवाटप 2 of
केलेलेआहे.
यापूव> मा.
उपिज्हािBकारी(भूसंपदन) सोको्हापूरयांनीता. आजरा, िज.
को्हापूर येथील उचंगी ल.पा.
तालावाम्ये रं. भूसं-६/ *वे्छा - उचंगी/एसआर/४७/९९अ, ब, क, ड/कािव-९२, िदनाक१५/०४/ २०१७रोजी्या िनवाडयावारेमौजे उचंगी, मौजे जेऊर, मौजे िचतळे, या गावातील बािBत रक्पर*तांना*वे्छापुनवसनअनुदानवाटपकेलेलेआहे. ता. आजरायेथील आंबेओहळरक्पातीलआदाळकरपेवाडी, उतूरयागावातीलरक्पर*तांना *वे्छापुनवसनअंितमिनवाडािदनांक१७/११/ २०१४रमाणे*वे्छापुनवसन अनुदानवाटपकेलेलेआहे.
तसेचको्हापूरिज्हातीलता.
भुदरगडयेथील नागणवाडील.पा.
तलावातीलमौजेबारवे, मौजेंदडेवाडी, मौजेमुरकुटे, येथील रक््रतांनादेखीलिदनांक१८/०३/ २०१६चेअंितमिनवाडयारमाणेपुनवसन अनुदानदेणेतआलेलेआहे.
तसेचमौजेतळेरे, ता. कणकवली, िज.
ंसBुदुग येथील ल.पा.
तलावतळेरेमBीलबािBतरक्पर*तांनादेखीलडे*कर२/उपिज/भूसं/ िजम/ *वेपुअिन/ उपिज्हािBकारी(भूसंपादन) िज्हामु्यालयंसदुदुग याअंितम िनवाडयादवारे*वे्छापुनवसनअनुदानवाटपकरतआहेत.
सदरपुनवसन अिBिनयमानुसारयापुव> देखीलसंपूण महाराटाम्येपुनवसनअनुदानवाटपकेलेले आहे."
4.
The above contention has not been taken into consideration by the Deputy Collector. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 2nd February 2024 passed by the Deputy Collector, Rehabilitation, Kolhapur is quashed and set aside and the said representation dated 4th December 2023 by the petitioners is remanded back to the Deputy Collector (Rehabilitation), Kolhapur for reconsideration.
5.
The impugned order has been set aside only on the ground that all the contentions raised in the subject representation are not considered. The Deputy Collector, Rehabilitation, Kolhapur shall decide the said representation on or before 30th June 2026. It is specifically clarified that all the contentions are expressly kept open.
3 of
6.
The Writ Petitions are disposed of in the above terms with no order as to costs.
[PRAVIN S. PATIL, J. ] [MADHAV J. JAMDAR, J.] 4 of