Siddhesh Jtoti E And F Wing Co Op Housing Society Limited v. Manav Builders Pvt Limited

Before : Shri E. B. Sivakumar, Addl. Registrar (O.S.) / Addl. Prothonotary and Senior Master Date: 6th March, 2026 CALLED FOR DIRECTION:

3. CHOL/ 148/2026 ) ) ) Shri Yash Sheth i/by Tushar Goradia, Advocate for the Applicant / Plaintiff.

Shri Praveen Maurya i/by BNS Legal, Advocate for Defendant No. 3.

IN S/171/2024 P.C.

By this Chamber Order the Plaintiff applies for liberty to serve the Writ of Summons upon (1) Abdul Rub Sikandar Ali, Defendant No. 4; (2) Dawood Noor Mohd. Aglodia, Defendant No. 5; (3) Shaikh Salma Begum Abdul Rauf Shaikh, Defendant No. 6;

(4) Nizamuddin Gulam Rasul Maknojiya, Defendant No. 7; (5) Umar Gulam Rasul Sheliya, Defendant No. 8; (6) Shamsher Ali Ekram Ali, Defendant No. 9; (7) Hamid Dawood Manasia, Defendant No. 10; (8) Ilyas Abdul Rahim Saji,Defendant No. 11;

(9) Sajid Aziz Siddiqui, Defendant No. 12; (10) Maqbool Ahmad Khan, Defendant No. 13; (11) Asma Mohd. Ali Chatrisa, Defendant No. 14; (12) Shaikh Hamidabi Zarina Shaikh, Defendant No. 15;

(13) Idris Ibrahim Vanara, Defendant No. 16; (14) Mohd. Ali Haji Anwar, Defendant No.17; (15) Usman Nasir Maredia, Defendant No.18; (16) A. Basit Yakub Loriya, Defendant No.19; (17) Shenaz Jaffer Ikramali, Defendant No.20; (18) Abdul Rahim Abdul Rub Shaikh, Defendant No. 21; (19) Abdul Mugni Sikander Ali Shaikh, Defendant No. 22; (20) Irfan Gulam Rasul Maknojia, Defendant No. 23; (21) Abdul Wahid Abdul Gani Shaikh, Defendant No. 24; (22)

: 2 :

Rafique Abdulla Cheena, Defendant No. 25; (23) Sultana Salim Shaikh, Defendant No. 26; (24) Mohd. Hussain Ibrahim Momaya, Defendant No. 27; (25) Mubashra Mansur Sayyed, Defendant No. 28; (26) Abdul Sharif Sayyed, Defendant No. 29; (27) Mohd. Aslam Riyasat Hussain Khan,Defendant No.30; (28) Lokman Yusuf Momin, Defendant No. 31; (29) Abdul Majid Siddqui, Defendant No. 32;

(30) Abdul Rahim Alludin Sheliya, Defendant No. 33; (31) Nazair Salim, Defendant No. 34; (32) Idris Habib Sunasara, Defendant No. 35; (33) Nizamuddin Abdul Wahid, Defendant No. 36; (34) Rasul Ibrahim Sunasara, Defendant No. 37; (35) Mohd. Iqbal Suleman Ansari, Defendant No. 38; (36) Shabbirali Yaqub Sunasara, Defendant No. 39; (37) Jagrala Rizwan Abdullah, Defendant No. 40; (38) Shirinbai Hasanali Kanodwala, Defendant No. 41; (39) Saifuddin Nazarali Nazari, Defendant No.42; (40) Sarabai Fida Hussain, Defendant No. 43; (41) Farida A. Hussain, Defendant No. 44; (42) Mohd. Sajid Husain, Defendant No. 45; (43) Suresh Kashinath Kamble, Defendant No. 46; (44) Mohd. Jafar / Firoz Abbas, Defendant No. 47; (45) Harishankar Sonawale, Defendant No.48; (46) Sauri Jaan Umar Khan, Defendant No.49; (47) Amina Ahmed Hans Lood, Defendant No.

50; (48) Idris Akbar Maknojiya, Defendant No.51; (49) Abdul Hasan Haroon Sheliya, Defendant No.52; (50) Ataur Rehman Machaliya, Defendant No. 53; (51) Fatima Abdul Rub, Defendant No.54; (52) Habib Dawood Kadiwala, Defendant No.55; (53) Ismail Noor Mohd. Sheliya, Defendant No.56; (54) Abdul Hamid Taj Mohd. Sheliya, Defendant No.57; (55) Sayara Abdul Majid Chowdhary, Defendant No.58; (56) Abdullah Jalai Police, Defendant No.59; (57) Yasin Abdul Rahim Sunasara, Defendant No.

: 3 :

No.61; (59) Rehan Usman Nedaria, Defendant No.62; (60) Abdul Majid Abdul Gani Chowdhary, Defendant No. 63; (61) Mohd. Amir Machaliya, Defendant No. 64; (62) Imran Jamal Palsaniya, Defendant No. 65; (63) Abida Abdul Kadir, Defendant No. 66; (64) Mohd. Swaleh Qureshi, Defendant No. 67; (65) Abbasali Dawood Kadiwala, Defendant No. 68; (66) Asraf Yusuf Palsaniya, Defendant No. 69; (67) Haiderali Dawood Kadiwala, Defendant No. 70; (68) Ikram Ali Umrao Hussain, Defendant No. 71; (69) Yunus Habib Kharawala, Defendant No. 72; (70) Rubabbai & Ali Asgar, Defendant No. 73; (71) Yusuf Ahmed Menon, Defendant No. 74; (72) Qamar Abbas Sayed, Defendant No. 75; (73) Farooq Fatheh Mohammed, Defendant No. 76; (74) Maimon U. Khan, Defendant No. 77; (75) Shaikh Abdul Jabbar Kasamali, Defendant No. 78; (76) Gangadar M. Gaikwad, Defendant No. 79; (77) Mohd.

Arif Syed, Defendant No. 80; (78) Hajra Begum Hamid Jafri, Defendant No. 81; (79) Mohd. Suleman Mohd. Hasan, Defendant No. 82; (80) Abdul Rehman Abdulrahim Shaikh, Defendant No. 83; (81) Subadra Bhiku Doiphode, Defendant No. 84; (82) Inaciociatan Alphonso And Anthony Bonnet Alphonso, Defendant No. 85; (83) Abdul Wahid Abdul Momin Shaikh, Defendant No. 86; (84) Abdul Ahad Reshmwala, Defendant No. 87; by way of substituted service by publishing in two newspapers viz. "Free Press Journal" in English language and "Navshakti" in vernacular language i.e. Marathi as per schedule annexed to the Chamber Order.

2.

Heard. Ld. Advocate for the Plaintiffs submits that, the Writ of Summons sent for service upon the Defendant Nos. 4 to 87 through the Sheriff of Bombay could not be effected as the building of the Defendants where they reside is demolished. He, therefore,

: 4 :

prays that, the Plaintiffs be permitted to serve the Writ of Summons by way of substituted service.

3.

Perused the affidavit in support. The Bailiff report dated 24th June, 2025 is at Exhibit "A" to the affidavit in support. 4.

For the reasons mentioned in the affidavit in support the Chamber Order is allowed and the same is signed separately. Plaintiff to publish the Writ of Summons in two newspapers viz. "Free Press Journal" in English language and in "Navshakti" in vernacular language i.e. Marathi, as per schedule annexed to the Chamber Order within four weeks from the date of uploading this Order.

06.03.2026 Addl. Registrar (O.S.) / Addl. Prothonotary and Senior Master sbk